烧伤客观瘢痕量表(BOSS):基于客观测量设备的烧伤瘢痕量表面板验证
结果显示Cutometer R0、Dermascan瘢痕厚度和强度及其与正常皮肤的比值组合AUC最高(0.786),总分≥5(共6参数)时灵敏度69.0%、特异度83.3%。
要点
- Cutometer R0比值与Dermascan瘢痕厚度、强度是预测增生性瘢痕的最准确客观参数。
- 颜色测量中瘢痕与正常皮肤比值优于单一参数,红斑和色素均如此。
- 客观全局评分总分≥5(共6参数)时灵敏度69.0%、特异度83.3%。
核心结论
- DSM II色度计、Cutometer和Dermascan高频超声的客观参数具有中等至强ROC AUC值。
- Cutometer R0与Dermascan瘢痕厚度和强度组合可构建客观全局瘢痕量表,准确区分增生性烧伤瘢痕与非增生性瘢痕或正常皮肤。
研究设计与样本
- 计算各客观参数预测mVSS≥6的ROC AUC,并将最准确参数组合成客观全局瘢痕评分。
主要发现
- ROC AUC最高者为Dermascan瘢痕厚度(0.897)、真皮强度及强度比(0.914和0.919)、Cutometer R0值(0.942)及R0比值(0.944)。
- 颜色测量中瘢痕与正常皮肤比值优于单一参数:DSM II红斑比值vs红斑(0.885 vs 0.818),a*比值vs a*(0.848 vs 0.741);黑色素比值vs黑色素(0.854 vs 0.761),L*比值vs L*(0.862 vs 0.767)。
- Cutometer R0、Dermascan瘢痕厚度、强度及其各自瘢痕与正常皮肤比值组合的AUC最高(0.786)。
- 总分≥5(共6参数)时联合灵敏度69.0%、特异度83.3%最高。
关键数值与推荐
- 预测mVSS≥6的ROC AUC:Dermascan瘢痕厚度0.897,真皮强度0.914,强度比0.919,Cutometer R0值0.942,R0比值0.944。
- 颜色参数ROC AUC:DSM II红斑比值0.885、红斑0.818;a*比值0.848、a*0.741;黑色素比值0.854、黑色素0.761;L*比值0.862、L*0.767。
- 组合参数(Cutometer R0、Dermascan瘢痕厚度、强度及各自比值)AUC为0.786。
- 客观全局评分总分≥5(共6参数)时灵敏度69.0%、特异度83.3%。
临床怎么用
- 可采用Cutometer R0、Dermascan瘢痕厚度和强度及其与正常皮肤的比值构建客观全局瘢痕评分。
- 该评分有助于客观区分增生性烧伤瘢痕与非增生性瘢痕或正常皮肤,辅助临床决策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Hypertrophic scars in burn survivors are a major cause of morbidity but the development of evidence based treatments is hampered by the lack of objective measurements of these scars. The objective of our study is to investigate the most accurate parameters for objective scar assessment and to create a combination score to facilitate the use of a panel of objective scar measurement tools. METHODS: Three independent assessors evaluated fifty five scar sites on fifty five burn patients with both the subjective modified Vancouver Scar Scale (mVSS) and a panel of objective measurement tools including the DSM II Colormeter, Cutometer, Dermascan high frequency ultrasound. The sensitivity and specificity of the objective scar parameters in predicting a mVSS score of 6 or more using the Receiving Operator Characteristic Area under the curve (ROC AUC) was then calculated and the most accurate parameters were combined to create an objective global scar score. RESULTS: The ROC AUC values were found to be highest for the Dermascan scar thickness (0.897), dermal intensity and intensity ratio (0.914 and 0.919), Cutometer R0 value (0.942), and R0 ratio (0.944). For colour measurements, ratios of scar to normal skin performed better than the single parameters for both erythema and pigmentation measurements: DSM II Erythema ratio vs Erythema (0.885 vs 0.818), DSM II a* ratio vs a* (0.848 vs 0.741); DSM II Melanin ratio vs Melanin (0.854 vs 0.761), DSM II L* ratio vs L* (0.862 vs 0.767). Analysis of the ROC AUC with chi-square test values showed that the highest AUC (0.786) was obtained with the combination of the Cutometer R0, Dermascan scar thickness, intensity and their respective scar to normal skin ratios. A total score of 5 and above (out of 6 parameters) had the highest combined sensitivity (69.0%) and specificity (83.3%). CONCLUSION: The objective parameters for the DSM II Colormeter, Cutometer and Dermascan high frequency ultrasound were all found to have moderate to strong ROC AUC values and combination of the Cutometer R0 and Dermascan scar thickness and intensity values can be used to create an objective global scar scale that can accurately differentiate patients with hypertrophic burn scarring from non-hypertrophic scars or normal skin.
引用
- Lee KC, Bamford A, Gardiner F, et al. Burns objective scar scale (BOSS): Validation of an objective measurement devices based burn scar scale panel. Burns. 2019. PMID: 31708256. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2019.05.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。