移植后猪烧伤瘢痕的点阵CO2激光消融:越深越好吗?
本研究在猪烧伤瘢痕移植模型上比较点阵CO2激光不同脉冲能量(20、70、150mJ)的疗效。结果显示激光消融孔深度随能量增加而增加,但瘢痕面积、颜色、生物力学等指标与对照组无显著差异,仅粗糙度呈剂量依赖性改善但无统计学意义,提示激光能量对结局影响不大。
要点
- 点阵CO2激光消融孔深度随脉冲能量增加而增加,但70与150mJ间仅小幅增加。
- 各能量激光治疗均未显著改善瘢痕面积、颜色及生物力学属性。
- 瘢痕粗糙度随能量增加呈剂量依赖性改善但无统计学意义,需客观对照进一步验证。
核心结论
- 点阵CO2激光消融孔深度与脉冲能量非线性相关,70至150mJ间深度仅小幅增加。
- 各能量激光治疗对瘢痕属性均无统计学显著获益,提示能量差异对结局影响不大。
研究设计与样本
- 在红色杜洛克猪背部制作全层烧伤创面,削痂后移植1.5:1扩展的刃厚自体皮片。
- 愈合4周后,每4周一次共3次,分别以20、70、150mJ点阵CO2激光5%密度治疗或不予治疗对照。
- 于第28、56、83天及末次治疗后4周(第112天)评估瘢痕面积、色素、红斑、粗糙度、组织学与生物力学,第112天活检行基因表达分析。
主要发现
- 激光消融孔深度随脉冲能量增加而增加,20mJ组孔宽度较小,70与150mJ组宽度无显著差异。
- 各能量激光治疗组与对照组相比,瘢痕面积、颜色、生物力学均无显著改变。
- 平均瘢痕粗糙度随激光能量呈剂量依赖性改善,150mJ组最平滑,但差异无统计学意义。
- 基质金属蛋白酶9基因表达在70或150mJ治疗瘢痕中较对照组和20mJ组轻微上调。
临床怎么用
- 点阵CO2激光治疗烧伤瘢痕时,增加脉冲能量至150mJ并未显著改善瘢痕面积、颜色或生物力学。
- 临床决策应基于客观定量指标而非单纯追求更深消融,需进一步开展设非治疗对照的临床研究验证疗效。
局限性
- 研究为猪模型,结果外推至人类需谨慎。
- 样本量未报告,可能影响统计效能。
- 仅评估至末次治疗后4周,长期效果未知。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Fractional CO2 lasers have been used in clinical settings to improve scarring following burn injury. Though used with increasing frequency, the appropriate laser settings are not well defined and overall efficacy of this therapy has not been definitively established. As it has been proposed that for thick hypertrophic scars proportionally greater fluence and thus deeper ablation into the scar tissue would be most effective, the goal of this study was to examine the role of ablation depth on scar outcomes in a highly-controlled porcine model for burn scars-after grafting. METHODS: Properties of laser ablated wells were quantified on ex vivo pig skin as a function of laser energy (20, 70 or 150mJ). Full-thickness burn wounds were created on the dorsum of red Duroc pigs with the eschar excised and grafted with a split-thickness autograft meshed and expanded 1.5:1. After four weeks of healing, sites were treated with either 20, 70, or 150mJ pulse energy from a fractional CO2 laser at 5% density or left untreated as a control. Sites were treated every four weeks with three total sessions. Scar area, pigmentation, erythema, roughness, histology, and biomechanics were evaluated prior to each laser treatment at day 28, 56, and 83, as well as four weeks after the final laser treatment, day 112. Additional biopsies were collected at day 112 for gene expression analysis. RESULTS: The depth of the laser ablated wells increased with increasing pulse energy while the width of the wells was smaller in the 20mJ group and not significantly different in the 70 and 150mJ groups. Scar properties (area, color, biomechanics) were not significantly altered by laser therapy at any of the laser energies tested versus controls. Average scar roughness was improved by laser therapy in a dose dependent manner with scars treated with 150mJ of energy having the smoothest surface; however, these changes were not statistically significant. Assessment of matrix metalloproteinase 9 gene expression showed a slight upregulation in scars treated with 70 or 150mJ versus control scars and scars treated with 20mJ pulse energy. CONCLUSION: The current study demonstrated that the properties of the ablative well (depth and width) are not linearly correlated with laser pulse energy, with only a small increase in well depth at energies between 70 and 150mJ. Overall, the study suggests that there is little difference in outcomes as a function of laser energy. Fractional CO2 laser therapy did not result in any statistically significant benefit to scar properties assessed by quantitative, objective measures, thus highlighting the need for additional clinical investigation of laser therapy efficacy with non-treated controls and objective measures of outcome.
引用
- Baumann ME, Blackstone BN, Malara MM, et al. Fractional CO2 laser ablation of porcine burn scars after grafting: Is deeper better? Burns. 2019. PMID: 31767253. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2019.10.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。