重新评估鼻整形培训模式:聚焦特定操作的模拟训练作用
该研究结合系统综述与在线调查,评估加拿大和美国整形外科住院医师的鼻整形培训现状。作者认为应发展针对特定操作的鼻整形模拟器以提升胜任力。
要点
- 高年资住院医师鼻整形暴露以观察或第一助手为主,动手机会不足。
- 住院医师认为鼻截骨、鼻尾侧中隔/前鼻棘操作和鼻尖缝合最难。
- 73.9%的住院医师认为模拟器训练可显著提升信心。
核心结论
- 住院医师鼻整形暴露充足但动手操作少,信心低于其他美容手术,需发展针对特定操作的模拟器。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述遵循PRISMA指南,同时开展在线调查评估加拿大和美国整形外科住院医师的鼻整形培训与舒适度。
主要发现
- 住院医师认为最难的三个步骤是鼻截骨(76.1%)、鼻尾侧中隔/前鼻棘操作(65.2%)和鼻尖缝合(55.8%),73.9%认为模拟器训练可显著提升信心。
临床怎么用
- 在胜任力导向培训中,可针对鼻截骨、鼻尾侧中隔/前鼻棘操作和鼻尖缝合等难点引入模拟器训练。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Rhinoplasty is known for its complexity in planning and execution. For trainees, knowledge acquisition is often adequately attained. The mastery of skills, however, occurs by means of hands-on exposure, which continues to be a challenge. This article discusses the positive progress made in rhinoplasty training, and objectively demonstrates a need for more hands-on rhinoplasty exposure for residents. METHODS: A systematic review was performed in adherence to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. Concurrently, an online survey was developed, assessing resident comfort and training in rhinoplasty, and e-mailed to Canadian and U.S. plastic surgery training programs. RESULTS: ONE HUNDRED THIRTY-EIGHT: residents completed the survey, 62 junior (first- to third-year residents) and 76 senior residents (fourth- to sixth-year residents). Seventy-two percent of senior residents (95 percent of sixth-year residents) reported adequate rhinoplasty exposure, as opposed to 13 percent of junior residents. Seventy-five percent of senior residents most often participated as observers or first assistants, 25 percent participated as co-surgeons, and 73.9 percent did not perform a key rhinoplasty step more than five times. Residents felt the three most difficult steps of rhinoplasty were nasal osteotomy (76.1 percent), caudal septum/anterior nasal spine manipulation (65.2 percent), and nasal tip sutures (55.8 percent), and 73.9 percent felt that simulator training would substantially improve confidence. CONCLUSIONS: Despite sufficient exposure to rhinoplasties, residents were least confident in performing rhinoplasties relative to other aesthetic procedures, likely because of the high proportion of rhinoplasty exposure that is observational as opposed to hands-on acquisition of surgical maneuvers in the operating room. The survey established the maneuvers residents find the most difficult, and as programs adopt competency-based training, developing rhinoplasty simulators targeting specific identified steps may help improve competence for rhinoplasty skills.
引用
- Zammit D, Ponnudurai N, Safran T, et al. Reevaluating the Current Model of Rhinoplasty Training and Future Directions: A Role for Focused, Maneuver-Specific Simulation. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2019. PMID: 31568292. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000005911
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。