加巴喷丁、氯胺酮、右美托咪定与安桃乐在烧伤换药镇痛中的比较
一项单盲随机对照研究纳入25例体表面积20%–50%的二度或三度烧伤患者,比较加巴喷丁、氯胺酮、右美托咪定和安桃乐四组的镇痛效果、恶心呕吐及血流动力学。结果显示四药均有显著镇痛效果,安桃乐镇痛最佳且不良反应和血流动力学变化最少,但面罩给药限制应用;加巴喷丁镇痛良好但可致血压和心率逐渐下降,因口服且常较便宜可考虑为首选。
要点
- 安桃乐镇痛效果最佳、不良反应及血流动力学变化最少
- 加巴喷丁镇痛良好但可致血压和心率逐渐下降
- 加巴喷丁因口服且常较便宜可考虑作为首选药物
核心结论
- 加巴喷丁、氯胺酮、右美托咪定和安桃乐对烧伤患者疼痛均有显著治疗效果。
- 安桃乐镇痛效果最佳、不良反应最少、血流动力学变化最少,但面罩给药限制其应用。
- 加巴喷丁镇痛良好但可致血压和心率逐渐下降并有不良反,因口服且常较便宜可考虑为首选。
研究设计与样本
- 单盲随机对照比较研究,采用区组随机化,研究者对区组大小保持盲态。
- 纳入25例体表面积20%–50%的二度或三度烧伤患者,分配至加巴喷丁、氯胺酮、右美托咪定和安桃乐四组。
- 记录人口学资料、血流动力学、不良反应和疼痛水平,于治疗前及给药后5、10、15、30、60、120、240和360分钟评估。
主要发现
- 四组药物对烧伤患者疼痛均有显著治疗效果。
- 安桃乐镇痛效果最佳,不良反应和血流动力学变化最少。
- 加巴喷丁镇痛效果良好,但对血流动力学变量的影响较不理想,可致血压和心率逐渐下降并有部分不良反应。
- 安桃乐因面罩给药方式限制了在患者中的应用。
临床怎么用
- 安桃乐可作为烧伤换药镇痛优选,但需考虑面罩给药的可行性限制。
- 加巴喷丁因口服给药且常较便宜,可考虑作为首选药物,但需监测血压和心率下降。
局限性
- 安桃乐的面罩给药方式限制了其临床应用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
This study aimed to evaluate differences in the experience of pain, nausea, and vomiting, as well as the hemodynamic parameters including heart rate (HR) and blood pressure (BP) in burn patients across four pain treatment groups-i.e., gabapentin, ketamine, dexmedetomidine, and entonox. In a single blinded randomized comparative study, 25 burn patients with second- or third-degree burns between 20% and 50% of their body surface were assigned to different treatment groups by using block randomization, while keeping the investigator blind to the size of the block. We recorded demographics, the hemodynamics, adverse effects, and pain levels before the treatment and again 5, 10, 15, 30, 60, 120, 240, and 360 minutes postadministration of pain medication (after-treatment). Gabapentin ketamine, dexmedetomidine, and entonox had significant effects in treatment of pain in burn patients. Entonox had the best analgesic effect with the least adverse effects and hemodynamic changes. Gabapentin also had good pain management effects; however, it showed less desirable effects on hemodynamic variables. Entonox caused the least amount of hemodynamic changes and the least adverse reactions, but since the medication is delivered by a facemask it limited its application with our patients. Gabapentin offered good benefits but caused a gradual drop in BP and HR and had some unfavorable reactions. However, since it is administered orally and often is cheaper, it could be considered as the drug of choice.
引用
- Chaghazardi S, Hedari M, Bazargan-Hejazi S, et al. Comparing the Effect of Gabapentin, Ketamine, Dexmedetomidine, and Entonox on Pain Control in Burn Wound Dressing. J Burn Care Res. 2020. PMID: 31630182. doi:10.1093/jbcr/irz142
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。