两种手持三维表面成像设备与固定式扫描仪的验证及术中面部成像潜力评估
本研究以固定式Vectra XT为参考,比较手持消费级Sense 3D与专业级Artec Eva在面部三维表面成像中的精度与耗时,并对10例鼻整形患者行术中成像。Artec Eva全脸及各亚单位(除眼区)平均偏差小于0.5 mm,与Vectra XT精度相当,适合鼻整形术中客观记录;Sense 3D无法准确捕捉复杂面部表面,术中应用受限。
要点
- Artec Eva全脸及除眼区外各亚单位平均偏差小于0.5 mm,精度与Vectra XT相当。
- Sense 3D仅全脸及额部中央/外侧、内侧颊偏差类似,全脸评估变异性高。
- 鼻整形术中成像Artec Eva偏差低,Sense 3D偏差高,后者不适用于术中3DSI。
核心结论
- Artec Eva手持设备面部成像精度与Vectra XT参考图像相当,可作为鼻整形术中客观记录的可选工具。
- Sense 3D无法准确捕捉复杂面部表面,用于术中三维表面成像的实用性有限。
研究设计与样本
- 采用表面-表面均方根分析,将消费级Sense 3D和专业级Artec Eva与参考系统Vectra XT比较。
- 两名评估者在两个独立时段对成像体模和30名志愿者面部区域重复行三维成像。
- 使用两种移动设备对10例鼻整形患者行术中三维表面成像,并与术前参考图像比较。
- 计算组内相关系数评估重复测量信度。
主要发现
- Artec Eva全脸及除眼区外所有亚单位平均偏差低于0.5 mm。
- Sense 3D全脸偏差与Artec Eva类似,但其他区域仅额部中央、额部外侧和内侧颊偏差类似。
- Vectra XT和Artec Eva变异性低,而Sense 3D全脸评估变异性高。
- 与术前参考图像相比,鼻整形术中Artec Eva偏差低,Sense 3D偏差高。
临床怎么用
- 鼻整形术中可考虑使用Artec Eva进行客观面部三维记录。
- 不建议使用Sense 3D进行术中三维表面成像。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to compare accuracy and timing of two handheld, mobile three-dimensional surface imaging (3DSI) devices against an established non-portable medical imaging system, and to evaluate future intraoperative use for facial surgery. METHODS: Surface-to-Surface root mean square analysis was used to evaluate both a consumer device (Sense 3D) and a professional surface scanner (Artec Eva) against a reference imaging system (Vectra XT). Two assessors repeatedly 3D-imaged the facial region of an imaging phantom and 30 volunteers in two separate sessions. Using both mobile devices, intraoperative 3DSI of 10 rhinoplasty patients was compared with preoperative reference imaging. Intraclass Correlation Coefficient was calculated for repeated measurements. RESULTS: Artec Eva yielded mean deviations below 0.5 mm for the whole face and all subunits excluding the eye region. Sense 3D showed similar deviations for the whole face, but otherwise only in the central and lateral forehead unit and the medial cheek. Variability was low for both the non-portable Vectra XT and Artec Eva, whereas full-face assessment using Sense 3D resulted in high variability. When compared to the preoperative reference images, intraoperative rhinoplasty 3DSI revealed low deviations for Artec Eva and high deviations for Sense 3D. CONCLUSIONS: The 3D surfaces captured by Artec Eva showed a similarly desirable accuracy for facial imaging as Vectra XT reference images. This handheld device presents a suitable option for the objective documentation during rhinoplasty surgery. Sense 3D was unable to accurately capture complex facial surfaces and is therefore limited in its usefulness for intraoperative 3DSI.
引用
- Koban KC, Perko P, Etzel L, et al. Validation of two handheld devices against a non-portable three-dimensional surface scanner and assessment of potential use for intraoperative facial imaging. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2019. PMID: 31519501. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2019.07.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。