轻度烧伤患者直升机转运的过度使用:一个应被纠正的医疗系统问题
该5年回顾性研究分析616例烧伤患者,发现13%使用直升机转运(HEMS),其中53%为小面积烧伤(<20% TBSA且无需ICU/OR)。
要点
- 小面积烧伤(<20% TBSA且无需ICU/OR)患者未从直升机转运中获益
- HEMS转运的小面积烧伤中1/4经急诊处理后直接出院,死亡率均为零
- 准确分诊和烧伤中心会诊可识别无需HEMS的患者,降低费用而不影响救治
核心结论
- 小面积烧伤且无吸入性损伤或多发伤的患者不必要使用直升机转运,准确分诊可节省医疗系统费用而不影响救治质量。
研究设计与样本
- 5年回顾性分析,数据来自作者所在创伤登记系统,共纳入616例烧伤患者,分为HEMS组和地面转运(EMS)组。
主要发现
- HEMS组烧伤面积更大(13 vs 9 %TBSA;P = .002)、烧伤更深(P < .001)、住院时间更长(P = .003)、ICU入住率更高(P < .001)、死亡率更高(P = .003)。
- HEMS组转运距离平均为EMS组的5.5倍(88 vs 16 mi;P < .001)。
- HEMS组中53%为小面积烧伤,EMS组为73%;小面积烧伤亚组中HEMS转运距离更远(91 vs 18 mi;P < .001),EMS组急诊入住率更高(93% vs 68%;P = .005),但住院时间或<24小时早期出院率无差异。
临床怎么用
- 现场转运或院间转运前应进行准确分诊和烧伤中心会诊,识别无需HEMS、可安全地面转运或早期门诊随访的小面积烧伤患者。
局限性
- 单中心回顾性研究,数据来自作者所在创伤登记系统,结论外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Eighty-eight percent of all patients burned in North America suffer burns of less than 20% TBSA. These patients may need care at a burn center, but barring any inhalation injury or polytrauma, these patients do not require helicopter transport (HEMS). We sought to identify a cohort of patients suffering smaller burns who do not benefit from HEMS to establish significant health care system savings. A 5-year retrospective analysis of data collected from our trauma registry was performed. Patients were separated into two groups: HEMS and ground transport (EMS). A subanalysis was performed between those with smaller burns (<20% TBSA and no ICU/OR requirement). ED disposition, hospital length of stay, distance transported, and cost was analyzed. Of 616 burn patients presenting to our center, 13% were transported by HEMS, 46% by ambulance, and 61% by private vehicle. Of those transported via HEMS, 38% had been evaluated and treated at an outside hospital before transfer. Patients transported via HEMS had larger burns (13 vs 9 %TBSA; P = .002) and deeper burns (P < .001), longer hospital stays (P = .003), higher ICU admission rates (P < .001), and mortality rates (P = .003) compared with those transported by EMS. Transport distance was a mean 5.5 times greater (88 vs 16 mi) in the HEMS group (P < .001). Within this cohort, 53% of patients transported via HEMS suffered smaller burns, compared with 73% transported by EMS. A subanalysis of the smaller burns cohort showed increased distances of transport via HEMS (91 vs 18 mi; P < .001) and increased rates of admission from the ED in the EMS group (93% vs 68% by HEMS; P = .005), yet no difference in length of stay, or rates of early discharge, defined as <24-hour hospital stay. Fully 1/4 of those transported via HEMS with smaller burns were discharged from the ED after burn consultation, debridement, and dressing. Mortality in both was nil. Average cost per helicopter transport was US$29K. Accurate triage and burn center consultation before scene transport or hospital transfer could help identify patients not benefiting from HEMS yet safely transferrable by ground, or better served by early clinic follow-up, which would reduce cost without compromising care in this cohort. Annual patient savings approximating US$444K could be multiplied were non-HEMS transport universally adopted for smaller burns.
引用
- Roman J, Shank W, Demirjian J, et al. Overutilization of Helicopter Transport in the Minimally Burned-A Healthcare System Problem That Should Be Corrected. J Burn Care Res. 2020. PMID: 31504602. doi:10.1093/jbcr/irz143
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。