烧伤面积估算方法比较:Lund and Browder、e-burn与Mersey Burns
本研究在澳大利亚妇女儿童医院招募45名参与者,比较Lund and Browder(LB)、Mersey Burns(MB)和e-burn(EB)三种方法在模拟儿童烧伤中估算烧伤总面积(TBSA)和液体复苏的可靠性及可用性。结果显示烧伤新手组估算均值更高且方差更大,经验水平与应用使用在较大烧伤面积估算中存在显著交互作用。结论认为Mersey Burns和e-burn均能降低人为误差,其中e-burn在本研究中更受青睐。
要点
- 烧伤新手使用三种方法估算TBSA的均值更高且离散度更大。
- 经验水平与应用使用在较大烧伤面积估算中存在显著交互作用。
- e-burn和Mersey Burns可降低未培训或非专科 clinician 的人为误差。
核心结论
- Mersey Burns和e-burn均能降低人为误差,尤其来自未培训或非专科临床医生,但e-burn在本研究中更有利。
- 技术辅助模型是烧伤评估的未来,需进一步研究确定其对整体临床结局的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 验证性研究,参与者来自澳大利亚妇女儿童医院外科和急诊科,共45人。
- 参与者被分为烧伤新手组、烧伤经验组和烧伤专家组,在两名模拟儿童烧伤患者(A:12个月;B:4岁)上计算TBSA。
主要发现
- 参与者包括医生(49%)、护士(33%)、护理学生(11%)和医学生(7%)。
- 烧伤新手组在患者A中TBSA均值为28.8%,范围14-40.5%;在患者B中均值为37.4%,范围20-52.3%。
- 双因素方差分析显示,经验水平与应用使用在较大烧伤TBSA估算中存在统计学显著交互作用。
临床怎么用
- 在儿童烧伤TBSA估算中,可考虑使用e-burn或Mersey Burns作为临床辅助工具以减少人为误差。
- 对经验不足的临床医生,技术辅助工具可能有助于提高烧伤面积估算的准确性。
局限性
- 本研究为模拟儿童烧伤的验证性研究,样本量45人,结论需进一步临床结局研究验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: One of the greatest challenges in burn care is the estimation of a total burn surface area (TBSA). It is especially challenging and needs to take into account the growing proportions and the age of a paediatric patient. The aims of this study is to: (1) assess the reliability of the three modalities (LB, MB, and EB) in calculating the extent of burn injuries and fluid resuscitation, and (2) compare the features in terms of usability and efficacy. METHODS: Participants were recruited from Women's and Children's Hospital (WCH), South Australia's surgical and emergency department. Participants were introduced to LB, MB and EB, and then commenced calculation of TBSA on two simulated paediatric (patient A: 12 months, patient B: 4 years) burns. The participants were categorized into three groups; (1) Burns-naïve, (2) Burns-experienced, and (3) Burns-expert. RESULTS: A total of 45 participants took part in this validation study: doctors (49%), nurses (33%), nursing students (11%) and medical students (7%). The burns-naïve group demonstrated higher means in both patients and has greater variance, TBSA mean 28.8%, range 14-40.5% and mean 37.4%, range 20-52.3% in patient A and B respectively. Two-way ANOVA analysis shows a statistically significant interaction between the effects of level of experience and use of applications on estimation of TBSA in larger burns. CONCLUSION: Innovative software and mobile applications demonstrate a high potential as clinical adjuncts in achieving better health outcomes in any health care system. Both Mersey Burns and e-burn reduced the risk of human error particularly from untrained or non-specialised clinicians, however, e-burn proved to be more favourable in our study. Technology-aided models are the future of burns assessment, and further studies are warranted to determine their impact on overall clinical outcome.
引用
- Chong HP, Quinn L, Jeeves A, et al. A comparison study of methods for estimation of a burn surface area: Lund and Browder, e-burn and Mersey Burns. Burns. 2019. PMID: 31561927. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2019.08.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。