文献速递烧伤创面修复

纳米银泡沫、纳米银凝胶与胶原敷料治疗部分厚度烧伤的疗效比较

Comparison of efficacy of silver-nanoparticle gel, nano-silver-foam and collagen dressings in treatment of partial thickness burn wounds.
PubMed 文献 · Burns · 2019-08-02

这项单中心前瞻性队列研究在20例15-40%部分厚度热烧伤患者中,于三个随机选定区域同时使用纳米银凝胶、纳米银泡沫和胶原敷料。结果显示纳米银泡沫在第10天再上皮化60%-80%、第14天完全愈合、换药时间<10分钟比例、操作简便性和第5天疼痛评分下降方面显著更优,三种敷料安全性相当,瘢痕质量、成本和感染率无显著差异。

要点

  • 纳米银泡沫敷料在第10天再上皮化率和第14天完全愈合率显著高于纳米银凝胶和胶原敷料。
  • 纳米银泡沫组第14天换药时间<10分钟的患者比例显著更高,临床医生评价操作「极易」的比例也更高。
  • 纳米银泡沫组第5天疼痛评分下降更快,但2周时疼痛评分无显著差异,三种敷料安全性均良好。

核心结论

  • 纳米银泡沫敷料在部分厚度烧伤的再上皮化、愈合、操作简便性和耐受性方面优于纳米银凝胶和胶原敷料,且三种敷料均安全。

研究设计与样本

  • 单中心前瞻性队列研究,为期1年,纳入20例烧伤面积15-40%、伤后≤48小时的部分厚度热烧伤患者。
  • 每例患者在3个随机选定且烧伤深度和表面积可比的区域同时接受纳米银凝胶、纳米银泡沫和胶原敷料治疗。

主要发现

  • 第10天再上皮化60%-80%的患者数:纳米银泡沫16/20,纳米银凝胶10/20,胶原10/20(p=0.042)。
  • 第14天完全愈合患者数:纳米银泡沫11/20,胶原6/20,纳米银凝胶4/20(p=0.032)。
  • 第14天换药时间<10分钟的患者数:纳米银泡沫18/20,胶原6/20,纳米银凝胶6/20(p<0.001)。
  • 临床医生评价操作「极易」的比例:纳米银泡沫95%,胶原80%,纳米银凝胶78%(p=0.011)。
  • 第5天疼痛VAS评分:纳米银泡沫6,胶原8,纳米银凝胶8(p=0.038);2周时疼痛评分可比。

关键数值与推荐

  • 瘢痕质量(p=0.82)、成本(p=0.09)和感染率(纳米银凝胶7/20、胶原4/20、纳米银泡沫3/20;p=0.05)在三组间可比。
  • 需要皮肤移植覆盖的患者数:纳米银凝胶5/20,胶原3/20,纳米银泡沫1/20。

临床怎么用

  • 对于15-40%部分厚度热烧伤且伤后≤48小时的患者,可优先考虑纳米银泡沫敷料以促进再上皮化和愈合、缩短换药时间并减轻早期换药疼痛。
  • 纳米银泡沫敷料操作简便性更优,可能有助于减少临床操作负担。

局限性

  • 样本量较小(共20例),为单中心前瞻性队列研究,结果的普遍性需更大样本验证。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: This study was carried out to compare the efficacy of silver nanoparticle gel (SG), nanosilver foam (SF) and collagen (C) dressings in partial thickness burn wounds. METHODS: This was a single-center, prospective cohort study carried out over a period of 1 year on patients with 15-40% partial thickness thermal burns ≤48 h. Each patient received all three dressings (silver-nanoparticle gel, nanosilver foam, collagen) simultaneously at 3 randomly selected areas which were comparable in terms of burn depth and surface area. Efficacy of the dressings was assessed in terms of healing rates, time taken and ease of application, pain at dressing change, cost, wound-swab culture and scar quality (at 3 months). RESULTS: A total of 20 patients were included. In SF group, number of patients with 60%-80% re-epithelialization on day10 (SG: 10/20; C: 10/20; SF: 16/20; p = 0.042) and complete healing on day14 (SF: 11/20, C: 6/20, SG: 4/20; p = 0.032) was significantly higher. The time for dressing change was similar at admission (p = 0.918) and day 10 (p = 0.163), although majority of the patients in SF group needed less than 10 min. The time taken (<10 min) was significantly lower in SF group by 14th day (SF: 18/20 C: 6/20 SG: 6/20; p < 0.001). The ease of application rated by clinicians as "extremely easy" was significantly better in SF group (SG: 78%, C: 80%, SF: 95%; p = 0.011). There was a significantly faster decrease in pain scores in SF group by 5th day (VAS score SF: 6, C: 8; SG: 8; p = 0.038), however, pain scores were comparable at 2 weeks. The scar quality (p = 0.82), cost (p = 0.09) and infection rates (SG: 7/20; C: 4/20; SF: 3/20; p = 0.05) were comparable. The need for skin-graft cover was lower in SF group (SG: 5/20; C: 3/20; SF: 1/20). CONCLUSION: Nanosilver-foam dressings were found to be more efficacious for re-epithelialization, healing, ease of application, tolerance when compared to silver nanoparticle gel and collagen dressings in partial-thickness burns. All were found to be safe.

来源:Burns,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Erring M, Gaba S, Mohsina S, et al. Comparison of efficacy of silver-nanoparticle gel, nano-silver-foam and collagen dressings in treatment of partial thickness burn wounds. Burns. 2019. PMID: 31383609. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2019.07.019

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。