整形外科知情同意的有效性评估:患者与医生相互满意度的方法比较
结果显示医生认为第三种方法在了解患者期望、情绪和个人偏好方面最优;患者对第三种方法的总体满意度及评估个人偏好和需求的能力显著高于第一种,在评估期望方面高于前两种。结论认为SDM联合期望问卷有助于改善医患关系、提升知情同意质量。
要点
- SDM联合期望问卷是医生评估患者期望与情绪的最有用工具。
- 患者对SDM联合期望问卷的总体满意度显著高于传统访谈。
- 该方法可能改善知情同意并降低诉讼风险,但需进一步验证。
核心结论
- 对医生而言,SDM联合Expectation Questionnaire-Pgm是理解患者期望和情绪、通过共享决策改善医患关系的最有用工具。
- 第三种方法旨在更好地覆盖患者并改善知情同意,从而降低诉讼可能性并更好地评估不适合手术的情况。
研究设计与样本
- 每次访谈结束时,由一名整形、重建与美容外科专科医生填写关于对该方法满意度的问卷,患者同时填写关于对访谈满意度的问卷。
主要发现
- 对医生而言,第三种方法在调查患者期望、情绪和个人偏好方面优于其他方法。
- 对患者而言,第三种方法在总体满意度及评估个人偏好和需求的能力上显著高于第一种方法。
- 对患者而言,第三种方法在评估期望方面高于第一种和第二种方法。
临床怎么用
- 在整形外科知情同意过程中,可考虑采用共享决策(SDM)联合期望问卷(Expectation Questionnaire-Pgm)以更好理解患者期望和情绪。
- 该方法可能有助于改善医患关系、提升知情同意质量,并辅助评估患者是否适合手术。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The acquisition of signed informed consent is not always enough to ensure adequate medical protection. Particularly, in plastic surgery, improving the doctor-patient relationship by understanding the patient's emotions and expectations becomes a determining factor when choosing the best therapeutic strategy for the subject in question, which may also include nonsurgical eligibility. METHODS: Ninety patients with various plastic surgery disabilities were recruited and randomly divided into three groups: Patients in the first group underwent the ``traditional'' clinical interview, those in the second underwent the clinical approach called Shared Decision Making (SDM), and those in the third group received both the SDM and a questionnaire evaluating patient expectations (Expectation Questionnaire-Pgm). At the end of each interview, a specialist physician in Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery was asked to fill in a questionnaire regarding his/her satisfaction with the method used. Likewise, the patient filled in a questionnaire on his/her satisfaction with the interview. RESULTS: For the doctors, the third method was superior in investigating patient expectations, emotions, and personal preferences. For the patients, the third method scored significantly higher than the first one for overall satisfaction and ability to evaluate personal preferences and needs and higher than the first and second methods in assessing expectations. CONCLUSIONS: For doctors, the SDM coupled with the Expectation Questionnaire-Pgm proved to be the most useful tool to understand patient expectations and emotions and thus improve the medical-patient relationship through shared decision-making. The third method therefore aims for better patient coverage and improved informed consent, thereby reducing the likelihood of litigation and better assessing nonfitness for operation.
引用
- Morselli PG, Lippi A, Giorgini FA, et al. Informed consent in plastic surgery, evaluation of its effectiveness for mutual satisfaction of patient and doctor: Comparison of methods. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2019. PMID: 31326321. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2019.05.037
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。