脱细胞真皮基质节约型胸肌前即刻假体乳房再造:含成本分析的对比研究
加拿大单支付体系下的回顾性双组病历对照研究,比较保留脱细胞真皮基质(ADM)的胸肌前即刻假体再造与传统胸肌下两期再造。共纳入77例患者、116侧再造乳房,两组基线特征可比。胸肌前组随访次数更少(3.8 vs 5.4)、并发症更少(24.7% vs 35.6%),总成本低25%。
要点
- 保留ADM的胸肌前即刻假体再造随访次数少于胸肌下两期再造(3.8 vs 5.4)。
- 胸肌前组并发症发生率低于胸肌下组(24.7% vs 35.6%),包括animation deformity。
- 计入全部相关成本时,胸肌前即刻再造比胸肌下两期再造成本低25%。
核心结论
- 保留ADM的胸肌前即刻假体再造避免了胸肌下两期再造的多项缺点,包括胸大肌剥离、animation deformity和多次手术。
- 作为该主题首个对比性成本分析研究,本方法成本比传统胸肌下两期再造低25%,并发症情况相当。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性双组对比病历回顾研究,时间范围为2015年6月至2017年1月。
- 胸肌前组为采用保留ADM技术行胸肌前即刻假体再造的患者,对照组为行传统胸肌下两期ADM辅助再造的患者。
- 共纳入77例患者、116侧再造乳房,成本分析以加元计算并纳入所有可计数变量。
主要发现
- 两组在体型、人口学特征(包括年龄、糖尿病与吸烟状态)及接受新辅助化疗和乳房切除术后放疗方面均可比。
- 胸肌前即刻再造组随访次数为3.8次,胸肌下两期组为5.4次。
- 胸肌前组并发症发生率为24.7%,胸肌下组为35.6%,前者并发症更少,包括animation deformity。
- 计入全部相关成本时,胸肌前即刻假体再造比胸肌下两期再造成本低25%。
临床怎么用
- 在合适患者中可优先考虑保留ADM的胸肌前即刻假体再造,以减少随访次数、并发症与总体成本。
- 在单支付体系下进行卫生经济评估时,可将该术式较胸肌下两期再造低25%的成本作为参考。
局限性
- 为单中心回顾性病历回顾研究,样本量为77例患者、116侧乳房,随访时间范围有限。
- 成本分析基于加拿大单支付体系,结论外推至其他支付体系时需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Refined mastectomy techniques, the advent of new technologies and materials such as acellular dermal matrix (ADM), cohesive gel silicone implants, and intraoperative tissue perfusion analysis, have fueled a resurgence in prepectoral breast reconstruction. This article aims to compare an immediate direct-to-implant prepectoral ADM-sparing approach with the traditional subpectoral 2-stage immediate reconstruction. A cost analysis within a Canadian-run single-payer system is also presented. METHODS: A retrospective 2-group comparative chart review study was performed (June 2015-January 2017) to identify all patients who underwent prepectoral direct-to-implant breast reconstruction using an ADM-sparing technique. The comparison group consisted of patients having undergone traditional 2-stage subpectoral reconstruction with ADM. All countable variables were included in the cost analysis, which was performed in Canadian dollars. RESULTS: A total of 77 patients (116 reconstructed breasts) were included. Both the prepectoral and subpectoral groups were comparable in size, demographics including age, diabetic and smoking status, and receiving neoadjuvant chemotherapy and postmastectomy radiotherapy. Patients having undergone direct-to-implant prepectoral reconstruction benefited from fewer follow-up visits (3.8 vs 5.4, respectively) and from less complications (24.7% vs 35.6%, respectively) including animation deformity. In addition, direct-to-implant prepectoral reconstruction costs 25% less than the 2-stage subpectoral reconstruction when all associated costs were considered. CONCLUSION: Prepectoral implant placement avoids many of the disadvantages of the traditional 2 stage subpectoral reconstruction, including pectoralis muscle dissection, animation deformity, and multiple surgeries. As the first comparative cost analysis study on the subject, our ADM-sparing direct-to-implant prepectoral reconstruction method costs 25% less than the traditional 2-stage subpectoral reconstruction with a comparable complication profile.
引用
- Viezel-Mathieu A, Alnaif N, Aljerian A, et al. Acellular Dermal Matrix-sparing Direct-to-implant Prepectoral Breast Reconstruction: A Comparative Study Including Cost Analysis. Ann Plast Surg. 2020. PMID: 31335468. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000001997
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。