Fisher解剖亚单位法与改良Millard旋转推进法唇裂修复效果比较
本研究由同一术者比较改良旋转推进法与解剖亚单位法修复唇裂的术后效果。结果显示,分离完全性与不完全性唇裂后,旋转推进法在更多参数上出现不对称,提示解剖亚单位法效果受唇裂严重程度影响较小。
要点
- 同一术者比较两种唇裂修复法,解剖亚单位法在更多参数上对称性更优。
- 完全性唇裂中,旋转推进法在唇高、红唇高和鼻翼基底均显著不对称。
- 不完全性唇裂中,旋转推进法仅红唇高显著不对称,解剖亚单位法无显著不对称。
核心结论
- 分离完全性与不完全性唇裂后,旋转推进技术似乎在更多参数上出现不对称,而解剖亚单位法较少。
- 解剖亚单位技术的结果似乎较少依赖唇裂严重程度。
研究设计与样本
- 对同一术者实施的唇裂修复术后照片进行人体测量,比较改良旋转推进法与解剖亚单位法。
- 测量四个参数:唇高、唇宽、红唇高和鼻翼基底宽度,并计算裂侧与非裂侧的美学比率。
- 采用Steffensen标准进行定性分析。
- 使用单样本t检验评估各美学比率与完美比率1.00的差异。
主要发现
- 不完全性唇裂:旋转推进法在红唇高上检测到统计学显著不对称,解剖亚单位法无任何测量参数显著不对称。
- 完全性唇裂:旋转推进法在唇高、红唇高和鼻翼基底上检测到统计学显著不对称,解剖亚单位法仅在唇高上显著不对称。
关键数值与推荐
- 美学比率以裂侧与非裂侧测量值之比计算,完美比率为1.00。
- 采用Steffensen标准定性评估唇裂修复效果。
- 证据等级:治疗性,III级。
临床怎么用
- 对于完全性唇裂,解剖亚单位法可能在唇高、红唇高和鼻翼基底对称性上优于旋转推进法。
- 对于不完全性唇裂,解剖亚单位法在红唇高对称性上可能优于旋转推进法。
- 选择术式时可考虑解剖亚单位法以降低对唇裂严重程度的依赖。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: When analyzing cleft lip repair techniques, the modified rotation-advancement repair is most widely used; however, the anatomical subunit approach is gaining popularity. The purpose of this study was to compare the outcomes of these two surgical techniques performed by the same surgeon. METHODS: Anthropometric measurements were performed on postoperative photographs of cleft lip repairs performed by a single surgeon. As described by Rossell-Perry, four parameters were measured: lip height, lip width, vermilion height, and alar base width. An aesthetic ratio of cleft to noncleft sides for each measurement was used as a quantitative measure of outcome. Qualitative analysis of cleft lip repair was evaluated using the Steffensen criteria. RESULTS: TWELVE: modified rotation-advancement repairs and 10 anatomical subunit repairs were analyzed. A one-sample t test was used to assess the difference of each aesthetic ratio from the perfect ratio of 1.00. For repairs involving an incomplete cleft lip, statistically significant asymmetry was detected in vermilion height for the rotation-advancement repair and no measurements in the anatomical subunit approach. For repairs involving a complete cleft lip, statistically significant asymmetry was detected in lip height, vermilion height, and alar base for the rotation-advancement repair and in lip height for the anatomical subunit approach. CONCLUSIONS: THE AUTHORS': findings show that when separating the complete and incomplete cleft lips, the rotation-advancement technique seemed to have asymmetry in more parameters than the anatomical subunit approach. This seems to suggest that the outcomes of the anatomical subunit technique are less dependent on cleft lip severity. CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic, III.
引用
- Patel TA, Patel KG. Comparison of the Fisher Anatomical Subunit and Modified Millard Rotation-Advancement Cleft Lip Repairs. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2019. PMID: 31348353. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000005847
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。