整形外科随机对照试验摘要的报告质量评估
本研究评估了2011至2018年发表在影响因子前5的整形外科期刊上的126项随机对照试验(RCT)摘要对CONSORT摘要清单的遵循情况。结果显示,摘要平均仅遵循7项(SD±2)清单条目,试验注册、随机化方法和试验资金来源的报告率极低。结论认为对CONSORT摘要清单的遵循有限,可能影响临床解读。
要点
- 整形外科RCT摘要对CONSORT清单的遵循度普遍不足,平均仅7项(SD±2)。
- 试验注册、随机化方法和资金来源是报告最差的条目,报告率分别为4%、2.4%和0%。
- 摘要中关键试验细节的缺失可能误导临床决策,需积极推广CONSORT摘要清单。
核心结论
- 在影响因子前5的整形外科期刊中,RCT摘要对CONSORT摘要清单的遵循有限。
- 省略关键试验细节可能导致对试验结果的错误解读和不当的临床应用。
- 需要积极推广CONSORT摘要清单以提高RCT摘要报告质量。
研究设计与样本
- 计算机检索OVID MEDLINE数据库,纳入2011至2018年发表在影响因子前5整形外科期刊上的所有原始RCT。
- 由两名评审员独立且双盲(对期刊和作者设盲)地使用16项CONSORT摘要清单对摘要进行评分。
主要发现
- 共纳入126项RCT,分布于5本期刊:Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery(n=83)、JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery(n=8)、Aesthetic Surgery Journal(n=33)、Journal of Reconstructive Microsurgery(n=2)和Journal of Hand Surgery-European Volume(n=0)。
- 所有摘要的平均总体条目遵循数为7(SD±2)。
- 报告最差的条目为「试验注册」、「随机化方法」和「试验资金来源」,分别出现在4%、2.4%和0%的摘要中。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生在利用RCT摘要快速评估证据时,应意识到摘要可能遗漏试验注册、随机化方法和资金来源等关键信息。
- 在依据摘要做出临床决策前,建议查阅全文以确认试验的方法学质量。
- 鼓励在整形外科RCT摘要中主动遵循CONSORT摘要清单,以提高报告透明度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: When evaluating randomized controlled trials (RCTs), clinicians will often refer to the abstract for an initial assessment of the results and to determine whether a full-text review is warranted. OBJECTIVES: This project aims to assess the reporting quality of RCT abstracts published within the top 5 plastic surgery journals utilizing the Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials (CONSORT) for abstracts checklist. METHODS: A computerized database search of OVID MEDLINE was performed. All primary RCTs published within the top 5 plastic surgery journals (by 2016 International Scientific Indexing impact factor) from 2011 to 2018 were included. Two reviewers, blinded to journal and author, independently and in duplicate, scored abstracts employing the 16-item CONSORT for abstracts checklist. RESULTS: This review identified 126 RCTs that satisfied the inclusion criteria. Included studies were distributed across 5 journals: Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery (n = 83), JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery (n = 8), Aesthetic Surgery Journal (n = 33), Journal of Reconstructive Microsurgery (n = 2), and the Journal of Hand Surgery-European Volume (n = 0). Mean overall item adherence across all abstracts was 7 (SD ± 2). The most poorly reported items were "trial registration," "method of randomization," and "source of trial funding" and appeared in 4%, 2.4%, and 0% of abstracts, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: There is limited adherence to the CONSORT for abstracts checklist among RCT abstracts published within the top 5 plastic surgery journals. Given the reliance of clinicians on abstract reporting, omitting essential trial details can lead to an inaccurate interpretation of trial results and improper application in clinical practice. Active endorsement of the CONSORT for abstracts checklist is required to improve the quality of RCT abstract reporting.
引用
- Gallo L, Wakeham S, Dunn E, et al. The Reporting Quality of Randomized Controlled Trial Abstracts in Plastic Surgery. Aesthet Surg J. 2020. PMID: 31353409. doi:10.1093/asj/sjz199
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。