烧伤瘢痕主观与客观测量工具组内及组间信度研究
本研究评估一组主观与客观烧伤瘢痕测量工具的组内和组间信度,3名独立评估者对55个瘢痕及正常皮肤位点进行评价。结果显示mVSS和POSAS的组间信度低于可接受限,而Dermascan超声(真皮厚度、强度)信度极佳(>0.90),Scanoskin和DSM II多数指标信度可接受至优秀。客观工具整体表现优于主观量表。
要点
- mVSS和POSAS的组间信度低于可接受限(>0.70)。
- Dermascan超声真皮厚度和强度组内及组间信度均>0.90。
- 客观瘢痕测量工具信度可接受至优秀,整体优于主观量表。
核心结论
- 客观瘢痕测量工具表现出可接受至优秀的组内和组间信度,且表现优于主观瘢痕量表。
研究设计与样本
- 3名独立评估者对55个瘢痕和正常皮肤位点使用主观工具(mVSS、POSAS)和客观工具进行评价。
- 采用组内相关系数(ICC)测量信度,可接受标准为>0.70。
- 通过问卷评估患者对不同工具的满意度和瘢痕参数重要性。
主要发现
- mVSS和POSAS的组间信度低于可接受限。
- 对于红斑和色素沉着,Scanoskin和DSM II的所有测量(除b*值外)组内和组间信度可接受至优秀。
- Dermascan超声(真皮厚度、强度)组内和组间信度极佳(>0.90)。
- Cutometer R0(硬度)信度可接受,但R2(总体弹性)信度不可接受。
- 所有客观测量工具总体满意度评分良好;患者将瘢痕相关疼痛和瘙痒评为比外观更重要,但经多重比较校正后该发现不持续。
关键数值与推荐
- 信度可接受标准为组内相关系数>0.70。
- Dermascan超声真皮厚度和强度的组内及组间信度均>0.90。
临床怎么用
- 临床瘢痕评估可优先选用信度更优的客观工具(如Dermascan超声、Scanoskin、DSM II),主观量表信度有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Research into the treatment of hypertrophic burn scar is hampered by the variability and subjectivity of existing outcome measures. This study aims to measure the inter- and intra-rater reliability of a panel of subjective and objective burn scar measurement tools. METHODS: Three independent assessors evaluated 55 scar and normal skin sites using subjective (modified Vancouver Scar Scale [mVSS] & Patient and Observer Scar Assessment Scale [POSAS]) and objective tools. The intra-class correlation coefficient was utilised to measure reliability (acceptable when >0.70). Patient satisfaction with the different tools and scar parameter importance were assessed via questionnaires. RESULTS: The inter-rater reliabilities of the mVSS and POSAS were below the acceptable limit. For erythema and pigmentation, all of the Scanoskin and DSM II measures (except the b* value) had acceptable to excellent intra and inter-rater reliability. The Dermascan ultrasound (dermal thickness, intensity) had excellent intra- and inter-rater reliability (>0.90). The Cutometer R0 (firmness) had acceptable reliability but not R2 (gross elasticity). All objective measurement tools had good overall satisfaction scores. Patients rated scar related pain and itch as more important compared to appearance although this finding was not sustained when corrected for multiple comparisons. CONCLUSION: The objective scar measures demonstrated acceptable to excellent intra- and inter-rater reliability and performed better than the subjective scar scales.
引用
- Lee KC, Bamford A, Gardiner F, et al. Investigating the intra- and inter-rater reliability of a panel of subjective and objective burn scar measurement tools. Burns. 2019. PMID: 31327551. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2019.02.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。