前瞻性观察研究:比较烧伤外科医生对植皮愈合的床旁评估与照片辅助方法
结果显示床旁评估与数字图像分析及照片评估的ICC分别为0.64和0.69,Bland-Altman图分布宽泛;照片评估的评估者间信度达0.96,重复照片评估的评估者内信度良好(照片0.88,数字分析0.97)。结论认为床旁评估存在变异性,连续照片记录可补充临床管理或研究以获得更可靠评估。
要点
- 床旁评估植皮愈合百分比变异性较大,ICC仅0.64-0.69
- 照片评估的评估者间信度优秀(ICC 0.96)
- 数字图像分析重复评估信度良好(ICC 0.97)
核心结论
- 床旁植皮愈合评估变异性较大,照片记录连续创面进展可补充临床管理或研究以获得更可靠评估。
主要发现
- 床旁评估与数字图像分析相比平均ICC为0.64,与照片评估相比平均ICC为0.69,Bland-Altman图分布宽泛。
- 六名临床医生照片评估的评估者间信度优秀(ICC 0.96)。
- 重复照片辅助评估的评估者内信度良好:照片评估ICC 0.88,数字分析ICC 0.97。
临床怎么用
- 临床可采用连续照片记录创面进展,作为床旁评估的补充以提高植皮愈合评估可靠性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Appropriate graft healing after split-thickness skin graft and early recognition of complications (graft loss) are critical to burn patient management. Larger mesh ratio expansions and Meek micrografting may pose a greater challenge in estimating the percentage of wound healing. This study looks at the reliability of photograph assessments and the concordance of bedside evaluation to photograph assessments of wound healing after skin grafting. METHODS: Three assessment methods for percentage of wound healing after skin Grafting were assessed: (1) clinicians' bedside rating, (2) clinician assessment of high-definition photographs, and (3) digital image analysis through color subtraction using Adobe Photoshop. We compared each method using a mixed-effects model on absolute agreement using intra-class correlation (ICC) and Bland Altman (BA) plots. RESULTS: Fourteen burn patients were enrolled with 38 grafted wounds (100 sites). Bedside assessments had a mean ICC of 0.64 (compared to digital image analysis) and 0.69 (compared to photo assessment), with a wide range on BA-plots. Inter-rater reliability of photo assessment was excellent (0.96) among six clinicians. Repeated photo-assisted assessments had good intra-rater reliability (ICC: photo assessment: 0.88; digital analysis: 0.97). CONCLUSIONS: Bedside wound healing assessments show variability; photograph documentation of sequential wound progression could supplement active clinical management or studies for more reliable assessments.
引用
- Koetsier KS, Wong JN, Muffley LA, et al. Prospective observational study comparing burn surgeons' estimations of wound healing after skin grafting to photo-assisted methods. Burns. 2019. PMID: 31229300. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2019.05.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。