延期颌骨重建的虚拟手术规划分层算法
本文针对延期上颌下颌骨重建中缺少肿瘤标本、术中需大量推测的问题,提出基于虚拟手术规划的分层算法,包含患者特异性建模、镜像健侧与缩放常模数据三种技术。2009至2016年共分析16例延期重建,多数患者有既往手术史和术前放疗史;常模与镜像设计用于恢复正常解剖,但多数患者特异性设计需非解剖性重建以适应软组织限制。
要点
- 延期颌骨重建可按患者特异性建模、镜像健侧、缩放常模数据分层规划。
- 多数患者特异性虚拟设计需非解剖性重建以规避第二皮瓣。
- 虚拟手术规划可减少术中推测,但仍有皮瓣失败与硬件外露风险。
核心结论
- 虚拟手术规划相比传统皮瓣塑形技术在延期重建中具有固有优势。
- 基于可用影像与剩余自体解剖的算法化方案可实现准确规划后皮瓣移植,无需术中推测。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2009至2016年延期上颌下颌骨虚拟手术规划重建病例,共16例。
- 分析人口学、建模技术与手术特征。
- 证据等级为治疗性,IV级。
主要发现
- 16例重建中50.0%为伴移位的放射性骨坏死,37.5%为肿瘤性缺损。
- 81.3%患者有既往手术史,81.3%有术前放疗史,4例既往重建失败。
- 建模技术使用情况:基于既往影像的患者特异性建模43.8%,镜像健侧解剖37.5%,缩放常模数据18.8%。
- 多数患者特异性虚拟设计(71.4%)需非解剖性重建以适应软组织限制并避免第二皮瓣。
- 1例部分皮瓣丢失需第二游离皮瓣,1例完全皮瓣失败;硬件外露为最常见轻微并发症,其后为感染、裂开和窦道形成。
关键数值与推荐
- 患者特异性建模基于既往影像,占43.8%。
- 镜像正常健侧解剖占37.5%。
- 缩放常模数据占18.8%。
- 常模与镜像重建设计目标为恢复normal解剖。
- 71.4%的患者特异性虚拟设计需非解剖性重建。
临床怎么用
- 对延期颌骨重建可依据可用影像与剩余原生解剖选择建模技术进行分层规划。
- 软组织受限时可预先设计非解剖性重建以避免第二皮瓣。
- 需警惕硬件外露、感染、裂开、窦道及皮瓣失败等并发症。
局限性
- 为单中心回顾性病例系列,样本量16例。
- 证据等级为IV级,缺乏对照比较。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The absence of a tumor specimen from which to obtain measurements at the time of delayed maxillomandibular reconstruction introduces degrees of uncertainty, creating the need for substantial intraoperative guesswork by the surgeon. Using the virtual surgical planning environment, the size and shape of missing bony elements is determined, effectively "recreating the defect" in advance of the surgery. Three virtual surgical planning techniques assist the reconstructive surgeon: patient-specific modeling, mirroring the normal contralateral side, and scaled normative data. To facilitate delayed reconstruction a hierarchical algorithm using virtual surgical planning techniques was developed. METHODS: Delayed maxillomandibular virtual surgical planning reconstructions were identified from 2009 to 2016. Demographics, modeling techniques, and surgical characteristics were analyzed. RESULTS: Sixteen reconstructions were performed for osteoradionecrosis with displacement (50.0 percent) or oncologic defects (37.5 percent). Most patients had prior surgery (81.3 percent) and preoperative radiation therapy (81.3 percent); four had failed prior reconstructions. The following delayed virtual surgical planning techniques were used: patient-specific modeling based on previous imaging (43.8 percent), mirroring normal contralateral anatomy (37.5 percent), and scaled normative data (18.8 percent). Normative and mirrored reconstructions were designed to restore normal anatomy; however, most patient-specific virtual surgical planning designs (71.4 percent) required nonanatomical reconstructions to accommodate soft-tissue limitations and to avoid the need for a second flap. One partial flap loss required a second free flap, and one total flap failure occurred. Hardware exposure was the most common minor complication, followed by infection, dehiscence, and sinus tract formation. CONCLUSIONS: Virtual surgical planning has inherent advantages in delayed reconstruction when compared to traditional flap shaping techniques. An algorithmic approach based on available imaging and remaining native anatomy enables accurate reconstructive planning followed by flap transfer without the need for intraoperative guesswork. CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic, IV.
引用
- Stranix JT, Stern CS, Rensberger M, et al. A Virtual Surgical Planning Algorithm for Delayed Maxillomandibular Reconstruction. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2019. PMID: 30676509. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000005452
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。