文献速递瘢痕与激光

三维伤口扫描仪:一种新颖、有效、可靠且便捷的瘢痕面积测量工具

3-D wound scanner: A novel, effective, reliable, and convenient tool for measuring scar area.
PubMed 文献 · Burns · 2018-10-25

本研究构建四色规则与不规则基底瘢痕模型,由两名实验者分别用轮廓法、像素法和三维伤口扫描仪重复测量面积。三维扫描仪测量值与标准值比值0.982、变异系数最低,Spearman系数0.992,两名实验者间Cronbach系数均>0.90,平均测量时间38.87±3.45s,显著短于其他方法。

要点

  • 三维伤口扫描仪测量瘢痕面积准确性高、相关性最强且重复性好。
  • 两名实验者间Cronbach系数均>0.90,满足临床测量可靠性要求。
  • 平均测量时间38.87±3.45s,显著短于轮廓法和像素法。

核心结论

  • 三维伤口扫描仪在瘢痕面积测量中准确性、相关性和测量时间均优于其他方法,实验者间可靠性和重测稳定性满足临床测量要求。

研究设计与样本

  • 构建肉色、棕色、橙色和白色塑料瘢痕模型,每种颜色含规则和不规则基底各四个。
  • 选择两名人体模型,将瘢痕模型置于右颊、右下颌-颈部、右尺骨前臂、右小腿胫前区和背部进行测量。
  • 两名实验者分别用轮廓法、像素法和三维伤口扫描仪垂直测量瘢痕面积,每人测量三次。

主要发现

  • 各测量方法与标准值之间差异有统计学意义(P<0.05)。
  • 三维伤口扫描仪测量值与标准值比值为0.982,最接近1,且变异系数最低。
  • 三维伤口扫描仪Spearman系数为0.992,相关性最强。
  • 三维伤口扫描仪两名实验者间Cronbach系数均>0.90,重测稳定性高。
  • 三维伤口扫描仪平均测量时间为38.87±3.45s,显著短于其他方法。

临床怎么用

  • 三维伤口扫描仪可作为瘢痕面积临床测量的可靠工具,测量快捷且重复性好。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

This study aimed to investigate whether a three-dimensional (3-D) wound scanner could be used to measure the area of scars. Scar models were constructed using flesh-colored, brown-colored (simulating hyperpigmented scars), orange-colored (simulating scars with obvious vascularization), and white-colored (simulating hypopigmented scars) plastic. Each colored plastic was used to construct scar models with regular and irregular base surfaces (four each). Two human models were selected to simulate patients with scars, and the scar models were placed on the right cheek, right lower jaw-neck, right ulnar forearm, anterior tibial region of the right calf, and at the back of these human models for scar area measurement. Two experimenters separately measured the scar area vertically using the profile method, pixel method, and 3-D wound scanner. Each experimenter measured the scar area thrice. Regarding accuracy, we found significant differences between the data and standard value of various measurement methods (P<0.05); however, the ratio of the data and standard value using the 3-D wound scanner was 0.982, which was the closest to 1, and showed the lowest coefficient of variation. Regarding correlation, Spearman's coefficient using the 3-D wound scanner was 0.992, showing the strongest correlation. With respect to inter-experimenter reliability and stability of retesting, each Cronbach's coefficient of the 3-D wound scanner between the two experimenters was >0.90, showing high reliability; thus, fulfilling the requirements for clinical measurement. The 3-D wound scanner took an average time of 38.87±3.45s for measurement, which was significantly shorter compared that for other methods The 3-D wound scanner showed greater accuracy and correlation, and a shorter measurement time, compared with other measurement methods The inter-experimenter reliability and retesting stability of the 3-D wound scanner also fulfilled the requirements for clinical measurement.

来源:Burns,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jin J, Li H, Chen Z, et al. 3-D wound scanner: A novel, effective, reliable, and convenient tool for measuring scar area. Burns. 2018. PMID: 30509366. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2018.05.009

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。