整合医学在整形外科中的应用:文献系统综述
共分析29项研究,其中45%评估自然产物、55%评估身心练习;II级可重复证据支持山金车减轻鼻整形术后水肿、洋葱提取物改善瘢痕色素沉着、催眠缓解围手术期焦虑、针灸改善围手术期恶心。
要点
- II级证据支持山金车减轻鼻整形术后水肿、洋葱提取物改善瘢痕色素沉着。
- II级证据支持催眠缓解围手术期焦虑、针灸改善围手术期恶心。
- V级证据提示银杏和海带出血风险及针灸感染风险。
核心结论
- 高级别证据研究显示自然产物和身心练习在整形外科患者护理中具有应用前景,值得进一步研究。
研究设计与样本
- 共分析29项研究,其中13项(45%)评估自然产物,16项(55%)评估身心练习。
- 证据等级按美国整形外科医师协会证据评级与推荐分级评估。
主要发现
- II级可重复证据支持山金车减少鼻整形术后水肿、洋葱提取物改善瘢痕色素沉着、催眠缓解围手术期焦虑、针灸改善围手术期恶心。
- V级证据报告银杏和海带使用存在出血风险、针灸使用存在感染风险。
- 2000年后发表的自然产物研究占92%,身心练习研究占44%(P = 0.008)。
关键数值与推荐
- II级证据:山金车减少鼻整形术后水肿。
- II级证据:洋葱提取物改善瘢痕色素沉着。
- II级证据:催眠缓解围手术期焦虑。
- II级证据:针灸改善围手术期恶心。
- V级证据:银杏和海带出血风险、针灸感染风险。
临床怎么用
- 可基于II级证据在相应整形外科情境中考虑山金车、洋葱提取物、催眠和针灸。
- 使用银杏、海带或针灸时需警惕出血或感染风险。
- 临床决策应结合证据等级与患者具体情况。
局限性
- 部分证据等级较低(V级),高级别证据主要集中在少数干预措施。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Surveys have reported that as high as 80% of plastic surgery patients utilize integrative medicine approaches including natural products (NPs) and mind-body practices (MBPs). Little is known regarding the evidence of benefit of these integrative therapies specifically in a plastic surgery patient population. METHODS: We conducted a systematic review of studies in MEDLINE, PubMed, and EMBASE (inception through December 2016) evaluating integrative medicine among plastic surgery patients. Search terms included 76 separate NP and MBP interventions as listed in the 2013 American Board of Integrative Health Medicine Curriculum. Two independent reviewers extracted data from each study, including study type, population, intervention, outcomes, conclusions (beneficial, harmful, or neutral), year of publication, and journal type. Level of evidence was assessed according to the American Society of Plastic Surgeons Rating Levels of Evidence and Grading Recommendations. RESULTS: Of 29 studies analyzed, 13 studies (45%) evaluated NPs and 16 (55%) studied MBPs. Level II reproducible evidence supports use of arnica to decrease postoperative edema after rhinoplasty, onion extract to improve scar pigmentation, hypnosis to alleviate perioperative anxiety, and acupuncture to improve perioperative nausea. Level V evidence reports on the risk of bleeding in gingko and kelp use and the risk of infection in acupuncture use. After year 2000, 92% of NP studies versus 44% of MBP studies were published (P = 0.008). CONCLUSIONS: High-level evidence studies demonstrate promising results for the use of both NPs and MBPs in the care of plastic surgery patients. Further study in this field is warranted.
引用
- Ruan QZ, Chen AD, Tran BNN, et al. Integrative Medicine in Plastic Surgery: A Systematic Review of Our Literature. Ann Plast Surg. 2019. PMID: 30557187. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000001676
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。