颈部烧伤后瘢痕挛缩松解后三种皮片固定方法的比较评价
本研究为随机介入性比较研究,纳入10-50岁、挛缩超过3个月且松解后创面大于100cm2的患者,比较缝线打包、皮肤钉和氰基丙烯酸酯胶三种固定刃厚皮片的方法。结果显示皮肤钉固定耗时最短且费用适中,氰基丙烯酸酯胶固定疼痛最轻但费用最高,三组皮片成活率相近。
要点
- 皮肤钉固定耗时最短(平均7分钟),费用适中,皮片成活可靠。
- 氰基丙烯酸酯胶固定疼痛最轻(VAS 1.8),但费用最高(40.06美元)。
- 三种方法并发症经逻辑回归分析具有可比性,再植皮需求结论不明确。
核心结论
- 皮肤钉固定法耗时最少、费用可负担且皮片成活可靠。
- 氰基丙烯酸酯胶固定法疼痛最轻、皮片成活可靠但费用高于其他两种方法。
- 三组并发症经逻辑回归分析具有可比性,再植皮需求结论不明确。
研究设计与样本
- 随机介入性比较研究,纳入10-50岁颈部烧伤后瘢痕挛缩超过3个月且松解后创面大于100cm2的患者。
- 所有患者松解后均采用自体刃厚皮片覆盖创面,分为三组:缝线打包组、皮肤钉固定组和氰基丙烯酸酯胶固定组。
主要发现
- 固定操作平均耗时:缝线打包组34分钟,皮肤钉组7分钟,氰基丙烯酸酯胶组12分钟。
- 固定材料平均费用:缝线打包组10.23美元,皮肤钉组11.23美元,氰基丙烯酸酯胶组40.06美元。
- 去除敷料时疼痛/不适视觉模拟评分平均分:缝线打包组3分,皮肤钉组2.9分,氰基丙烯酸酯胶组1.8分。
- 平均皮片成活率:缝线打包组90.1%,皮肤钉组94.1%,氰基丙烯酸酯胶组93.8%。
- 逻辑回归分析以并发症为结局变量,保持各组变量恒定,三组具有可比性。
临床怎么用
- 对于颈部烧伤后瘢痕挛缩松解后的刃厚皮片固定,可优先考虑皮肤钉固定以缩短手术时间并控制费用。
- 若患者对疼痛敏感或追求更轻的去除敷料疼痛,可考虑氰基丙烯酸酯胶固定,但需考虑其较高费用。
- 缝线打包法虽耗时较长且疼痛评分较高,但皮片成活率仍可达90.1%,可根据实际条件选用。
局限性
- 再植皮需求方面的结论不明确。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Split thickness skin graft is an essential component of release of post burn contracture of neck. There are many methods of fixation of skin grafts; however, there is lack of objective comparison between different techniques. This study has been designed to compare three commonly used techniques of split thickness skin graft fixation methods. Surgical time, advantages, cost factor and post-operative outcome have been compared amongst three techniques. METHODS: A randomized interventional comparative study was conducted to compare three methods of skin graft fixation in patients of 10-50 years age group, with contracture of more than 3 month duration having more than 100cm2 skin defects after contracture release. Resurfacing of the defects after contracture release was carried out in all the groups using autologous split skin grafts. Patients were included in three groups; Group 1: tie over method, Group 2: skin stapler fixation and Group 3: Cyanoacrylate glue fixation. RESULTS: Mean duration of fixation procedure was 34min in tie over group, in skin stapler group 7min and in cyanoacrylate group 12min. Mean cost of fixation material was 10.23 USD in tie-over group, 11.23 USD in stapler group and 40.06 USD in cyanoacrylate group. Mean score of pain/discomfort (visual analog score) on dressing removal in tie-over group was 3, for skin stapler group was 2.9 and that for cyanoacrylate glue group was 1.8. mean graft take was found to be 90.1% in tie-over group, 94.1% in skin stapler group & 93.8% in cyanoacrylate glue group. On logistic regression analysis, keeping all the variables constant in the groups the complications as the outcome variable, three groups are comparable. The need for regrafting remains inconclusive. CONCLUSIONS: Skin stapler method for skin graft fixation was least time consuming, affordable and highly reliable when graft take success was considered. Cyanoacrylate glue fixation method was least painful and reliable in terms of graft take success though costlier than other two.
引用
- Samal CC, Dash S, Agrawal K, et al. Comparative evaluation of three methods of skin graft fixation for split thickness skin graft after release of post burn contracture of the neck. Burns. 2018. PMID: 30482616. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2018.09.030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。