山羊颅骨模型比较压电、经皮与鼻内连续截骨技术
本研究在山羊颅骨截骨模型中比较鼻内连续、外部穿孔和压电截骨三种技术,每组来自12只动物。压电组无粉碎性骨折和黏膜缺损,截骨处骨间隙和鼻黏膜损伤平均量低于其他组;鼻内组截骨时间更短,与外部和压电组相似。结论认为压电截骨可安全用于鼻整形。
要点
- 压电截骨组无粉碎性骨折和黏膜缺损。
- 压电组骨间隙和鼻黏膜损伤平均量低于其他组。
- 鼻内组截骨时间更短,与外部和压电组相似。
核心结论
- 压电截骨在山羊模型中产生更低的鼻黏膜损伤和粉碎性骨折,可安全用于鼻整形实践。
研究设计与样本
- 研究在山羊颅骨截骨模型上进行,12只动物分为鼻内连续、外部穿孔和压电截骨三组。
主要发现
- 压电截骨组所有样本均无粉碎性骨折和黏膜缺损。
- 压电组截骨处骨间隙平均量和鼻黏膜损伤低于其他组。
- 鼻内组截骨时间更短,与外部和压电组相似。
临床怎么用
- 在鼻整形截骨中可考虑使用压电截骨以减少黏膜损伤和粉碎性骨折。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Osteotomy is a crucial step in rhinoplasty, which can have a significant impact on the outcome. In addition to previous percutaneous (external perforating) and endonasal (internal) approaches, piezosurgery has been used in rhinoplasty practice since 2007. This experimental model was planned to compare the three osteotomy techniques. MATERIALS AND METHODS: This study was performed on a caprine skull osteotomy model. Three groups were created from 12 animals, namely, endonasal continuous, external perforating, and piezosurgery groups. All the groups were evaluated for bone gaps, comminuted fractures, and nasal mucosa damage. RESULTS: There were no comminuted fractures and mucosal defects in any of the samples in the piezo osteotomy group. The average amount of bone gap at the osteotomy site and the nasal mucosa damage was lower in the piezo group than in the other groups. The time required for the osteotomy was shorter in the endonasal group, similar to that in the external and piezo groups. CONCLUSION: New techniques are constantly being developed to achieve better results in rhinoplasty. As a natural consequence to technological developments, new devices are being introduced to rhinoplasty practice. Piezo is one such device. We have found that piezo osteotomy has resulted in lower amounts of nasal mucosal damage and comminuted fractures. We believe that piezo can safely be used in rhinoplasty practice until newer and more reliable technologies are being developed.
引用
- Kurt Yazar S, Serin M, Rakici IT, et al. Comparison of piezosurgery, percutaneous osteotomy, and endonasal continuous osteotomy techniques with a caprine skull model. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2018. PMID: 30243555. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2018.08.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。