儿童复杂颅颌面重建中定制CAD/CAM植入物的136例经验
回顾性分析2003–2014年单中心136例儿童复杂颅颌面缺损,采用CAD/CAM定制PEEK、PMMA或钛植入物行嵌入或覆盖重建;植入物感染并非均需取出,PEEK组感染较多,钛成本最高。
要点
- CAD/CAM定制植入物用于儿童复杂颅颌面重建有效但费用较高。
- 感染6例(4.4%),均见于PEEK组,3例经冲洗抗生素成功保植入物。
- 最终取出植入物5例(3.7%),因感染、钛晚期暴露或PMMA晚期骨折。
核心结论
- CAD/CAM全合成材料植入物治疗儿童复杂颅颌面畸形有效但费用较高。
- 植入物感染并不总是需要取出。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心回顾性研究,纳入2003–2014年接受CAD/CAM PEEK、PMMA或钛植入物行复杂嵌入或覆盖颅颌面重建的儿童患者136例。
- 男69例、女67例,平均年龄11.5岁(范围3–22岁),平均随访30个月。
- PEEK组72例、PMMA组42例、钛组22例;嵌入93例、覆盖43例。
主要发现
- 适应证包括先天畸形26.5%、去骨瓣减压25.0%、颅颌面综合征25.7%、肿瘤缺损14.0%、创伤后6.6%。
- 植入物费用PEEK为7703加元、PMMA为8328加元,均显著低于钛的11980加元(p < 0.0005)。
- 6例(4.4%)因感染需手术冲洗和抗生素治疗,其中3例成功保留植入物,所有感染均发生于PEEK组。
- 5例(3.7%)最终取出植入物,原因分别为感染(n=3)、钛晚期暴露(n=1)、PMMA晚期骨折(n=1)。
临床怎么用
- 儿童复杂颅颌面重建可考虑CAD/CAM定制PEEK、PMMA或钛植入物,需权衡费用与并发症。
- 出现植入物感染时,可先尝试冲洗和抗生素治疗以保留植入物。
- 文中提出重建算法可供临床参考。
局限性
- 回顾性单中心研究,未设对照组。
- 样本量有限,随访时间平均30个月。
- 未报告各组并发症发生率的统计学比较。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: CAD-CAM patient-specific implants offer cerebral protection and improved facial balance without the disadvantages of autologous bone grafting such as donor site morbidity and unpredictable resorption. Several alloplastic materials are available, but titanium, polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA), and polyetheretherketone (PEEK) are the current popular choices. We reviewed our experience of applying different alloplastic CAD-CAM materials in the reconstruction of complex pediatric craniofacial deformities. METHODS: A retrospective review was performed of all pediatric patients who underwent a complex inlay or onlay implant craniofacial reconstruction using CAD-CAM PEEK, PMMA, or titanium implants at a single institution. Demographics, cost, operative time, complications, and outcomes were assessed. RESULTS: Between 2003 and 2014, 136 patients (69 male; 67 female; mean age 11.5 years (3-22 years); mean follow-up 30 months) had custom patient-specific craniofacial reconstruction with PEEK (n = 72), PMMA (n = 42), and titanium (n = 22) implants (inlay = 93; onlay = 43). Indications included congenital anomalies (26.5%), decompressive craniectomies (25.0%), craniofacial syndromes (25.7%), tumor defects (14.0%), and post-trauma (6.6%). Implant cost varied significantly for PEEK ($7703 CAD) and PMMA ($8328 CAD) compared with that for titanium ($11,980 CAD) (p < 0.0005). Six patients (4.4%) required surgery due to infection consisting of irrigation and antibiotic administration with successful implant salvage in three patients. All infections occurred in the PEEK group. Five patients (3.7%) ultimately had implants removed due to infection (n = 3), late exposure (titanium; n = 1), or late fracture (PMMA; n = 1). CONCLUSIONS: CAD-CAM alloplast reconstruction in the management of complex pediatric craniofacial deformities is effective although expensive. Implant infection does not always require explantation. A reconstruction algorithm is presented.
引用
- Nguyen PD, Khechoyan DY, Phillips JH, et al. Custom CAD/CAM implants for complex craniofacial reconstruction in children: Our experience based on 136 cases✰. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2018. PMID: 30220563. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2018.07.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。