烧伤外科医生对自残烧伤的态度、信念与手术决策的定量与主题分析
研究通过问卷和假设病例调查37名烧伤外科医生对自残烧伤患者的态度、信念及手术决策依据。多数医生持积极态度,但约十分之一持更负面评判,约五分之一较少提供手术,近四分之一认为反复自残时手术应仅限有限次数。部分医生存在不准确信念,高年资医生较少评判且更倾向提供手术。
要点
- 多数烧伤外科医生对自残患者持积极态度,但少数存在负面评判和不准确信念。
- 高年资医生比低年资医生更少评判、更倾向提供手术且更少持有不准确信念。
- 部分医生的决策与英国自残损伤管理指南不一致,提示需加强相关教育。
核心结论
- 部分烧伤外科医生对自残烧伤患者的态度和手术决策与英国指南不一致,尤其在低年资医生中更明显。
- 需在烧伤服务中开展自残相关教育,并优先在职业生涯早期进行。
- 尚需前瞻性研究探讨自残后手术治疗的结局。
研究设计与样本
- 烧伤外科医生(n=37)完成问卷,测量对自残的态度和信念。
- 通过假设病例场景让医生做出手术决策并描述理由,结合定量与主题分析。
主要发现
- 多数医生对自残持积极态度,但约十分之一对自残患者评判更负面。
- 约五分之一较少提供手术,近四分之一认为反复自残时手术应仅限有限次数。
- 部分医生存在不准确信念,如自残是「寻求关注」、手术会强化自残、患者会破坏移植皮片。
- 主题分析识别五个主题:平等获得照护、多学科协作、陈旧或无益叙事、对破坏皮片的担忧、反复与首次自残发作。
- 高年资医生较少评判、更倾向提供手术干预、较少持有不准确信念。
临床怎么用
- 烧伤外科医生应反思对自残患者的评判性态度和不准确信念,避免影响手术决策。
- 在烧伤服务中开展自残相关教育,尤其针对低年资医生早期培训。
- 手术决策应遵循英国自残损伤管理指南,并加强多学科协作。
局限性
- 样本量较小(n=37),可能限制结果的代表性和推广性。
- 使用假设病例场景,可能与真实临床决策存在差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Self-harm injuries represent a significant minority of attendances within burns services. However, there is minimal research exploring burns surgeons' attitudes and beliefs about self-harm and how treatment decisions are made. METHOD: Burns surgeons (n=37) completed a questionnaire which measured attitudes and beliefs about self-harm. Surgical decision-making was also explored by prompting surgeons to make treatment decisions for hypothetical case scenarios, and describe their rationale behind their decisions. RESULTS: The majority of surgeons reported positive attitudes about self-harm. However, around one in ten judged patients who self-harm more negatively, around a fifth offer surgery less frequently and almost a quarter believed that surgery should only be offered a limited number of times in repeated self-harm. Unhelpful or inaccurate beliefs (e.g. self-harm is 'attention seeking,' surgery would reinforce the self-harm, and that patients who self-harm tamper with skin grafts) were evident in some surgeons. Thematic analysis of qualitative data describing surgical decisions identified five themes: Equal Access to Care; Multidisciplinary Working; Old or Unhelpful Stories; Concerns about Tampering; and Repeated vs. First Time Self-Harm Episodes. More experienced surgeons were less judgmental, more likely to offer surgical interventions, and less likely to hold unhelpful or inaccurate beliefs compared to junior surgeons. CONCLUSIONS: Some surgeons are not acting in line with UK guidance on the management of self-harm injuries. Education on the topic of self-harm is essential in burns services and this may be particularly important early on during surgical careers. Prospective research regarding surgical treatments and outcomes following self-harm is required.
引用
- Rai L, Shepherd L, O'Boyle CP, et al. Quantitative and thematic analysis of burns surgeons' attitudes, beliefs and surgical decision-making in self-harm burn injuries: The use of a questionnaire and hypothetical cases. Burns. 2018. PMID: 30181010. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2018.08.003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。