临床医生使用BuRN工具识别烧伤儿童虐待经验的定性分析
本研究通过三场焦点小组访谈,探讨急诊临床医生使用BuRN-Tool(烧伤忽视或虐待风险评估工具)的体验。25名急诊临床医生参与,所有参与者认为该工具可接受、有用且临床有益,尤其对 junior staff 和非儿科环境工作者。但案例情景揭示对充分监督、既往社会照护介入和全层烧伤等问题的解释存在主观性,导致评分差异。
要点
- 急诊临床医生普遍认为BuRN-Tool易于使用且临床有益。
- 工具对 junior staff 和非儿科环境工作者帮助尤大。
- 部分变量解释主观,导致评分不一致,需澄清问题。
核心结论
- BuRN-Tool在急诊环境中可接受,焦点小组对其布局、益处和使用持统一积极态度。
- 部分变量的主观解释导致评分不一致,需对问题进行澄清。
研究设计与样本
- 在威尔士大学医院急诊科为期六周开展三场焦点小组,25名急诊临床医生参与。
- 采用半结构化方法,预设开放式问题后应用案例情景,录音并逐字转录,进行主题分析,所有数据双编码。
主要发现
- 所有参与者表示使用BuRN-Tool辅助儿童虐待决策是可接受的。
- 所有参与者表示BuRN-Tool有用且直接明了。
- 所有参与者表示该工具临床有益,尤其对 junior staff 和不常处理儿科环境的人员。
- 案例情景识别出对充分监督、既往社会照护介入和全层烧伤等问题的解释存在主观性,导致评分差异。
临床怎么用
- 急诊临床医生可使用BuRN-Tool辅助识别烧伤儿童中的虐待,尤其适合 junior staff 和非儿科环境工作者。
- 使用时需注意对充分监督、既往社会照护介入和全层烧伤等变量解释的主观性可能影响评分一致性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The BuRN-Tool (Burns Risk assessment for Neglect or abuse Tool) is a clinical prediction tool (CPT) aiding the identification of child maltreatment in children with burn injuries. The tool has been derived from systematic reviews and epidemiological studies, validated and is under-going an implementation evaluation. Clinician opinion on the use of this CPT is a key part of its evaluation. OBJECTIVES: To explore the experience of emergency clinicians use of the BuRN-Tool in an emergency department (ED). METHODS: Three focus groups were conducted over a six-week period by the research team in the ED in the University Hospital of Wales; 25 emergency clinicians attended. A semi-structured approach was taken with pre-determined open-ended questions asked followed by a series of case vignettes to which the CPT was applied. The focus groups were recorded and transcribed verbatim. Thematic analysis was conducted for identification of pre-set and emergent themes. All data were double-coded. RESULTS: All participants said that it was acceptable to use the BuRN-Tool to aid in the decision-making process surrounding child maltreatment. All participants said that the BuRN-Tool was helpful and straight forward to use. All participants said that the tool was clinically beneficial, particularly for junior staff and those who do not always work in a paediatric environment. The clinical vignettes identified subjectivity in interpretation questions around adequate supervision, previous social care involvement and full thickness burns. This resulted in some variation in scoring. CONCLUSIONS: This study confirms that the BuRN-Tool is acceptable in an ED setting. The focus groups demonstrated a homogenous and positive attitude regarding the layout, benefits and use of the BuRN-Tool. The subjective interpretation of some variables accounts for the non-uniformity in the scores generated. Clarification of questions will be made.
引用
- Mullen S, Quinn-Scoggins HD, Nuttall D, et al. Qualitative analysis of clinician experience in utilising the BuRN Tool (Burns Risk assessment for Neglect or abuse Tool) in clinical practice. Burns. 2018. PMID: 30075971. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2018.03.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。