双侧乳房再造患者满意度比较:BREAST-Q问卷在降低风险与治疗性乳房切除术后的应用
该研究基于剑桥乳腺单元2008至2014年前瞻性登记数据,比较双侧乳房切除再造患者按手术指征(双侧治疗性、双侧降低风险或混合)分组的BREAST-Q满意度。共57例可用问卷,治疗组在乳房、结局、心理社会、性、躯体及信息等多个维度满意度高于降低风险组,混合组评分更低,BRCA突变阳性者最低。躯体健康各组维持,心理社会/性健康有差异。
要点
- 治疗性双侧乳房切除再造患者多数满意度维度高于降低风险者。
- 混合指征组评分较低,BRCA突变阳性患者满意度最低。
- 躯体健康各组相似,心理社会与性健康随指征变化。
核心结论
- 双侧即刻再造患者躯体症状与乳房切除指征无关,但风险平衡与诊断决策过程影响自我与手术满意度。
- 临床医生应将手术指征作为患者自我感知和手术体验的重要心理因素。
- 降低风险手术患者需重视术前期望管理。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性登记队列研究,纳入2008至2014年剑桥乳腺单元双侧乳房切除与再造患者,按指征分为双侧治疗性、双侧降低风险或混合。
- 使用总Dillman法邮寄BREAST-Q问卷,Q-SCORE软件分析满意度评分。
主要发现
- 治疗组在乳房、结局、心理社会、性、躯体及信息等多个维度满意度高于降低风险组。
- 混合组评分更低,BRCA基因突变阳性患者评分最低。
- 所有组躯体健康维持,心理社会/性健康有变化。
- 混合组和降低风险组中良好心理社会健康与更高结局满意度相关。
临床怎么用
- 术前评估应关注手术指征对患者心理的影响,尤其对降低风险手术者加强期望管理。
- 对混合指征及BRCA突变阳性患者可针对性提供心理社会支持。
局限性
- 回复率58%,样本量57例,可能存在应答偏倚。
- 单中心回顾性审计前瞻性登记数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Patients undergoing mastectomy and immediate breast reconstruction for cancer may be expected to have different perceptions of long-term outcomes compared with those who have this operation prophylactically. METHODS: Patients who underwent bilateral mastectomy and breast reconstruction from 2008 to 2014 at the Cambridge Breast Unit were identified from a prospective register and their notes were audited. They were classified according to their indication for surgery as follows: bilaterally therapeutic, bilaterally risk-reducing or combination. The BREAST-Q™ questionnaire was posted to participants using the 'total Dillman method'. Q-SCORE software was utilised to analyse patient satisfaction scores. RESULTS: Sixty-five (58%) responses were received, of which 8 were excluded, leaving 57 usable for the study. The therapeutic group had higher patient satisfaction than the risk-reducing group across most domains including breast, outcome, psychosocial, sexual, physical and information. The combination group scored lower and BRCA gene mutation-positive patients scored the lowest. Physical well-being was maintained across all groups but psychosocial/sexual well-being varied. Good psychosocial well-being was linked to a higher satisfaction with the outcome in the combination and risk-reducing groups. CONCLUSION: This study highlights the need for clinicians to take into account the indication for surgery as a major psychological factor in patients' perception of self and experience of surgery. It demonstrates that bilateral immediate reconstruction patients report similar physical symptoms irrespective of indication for mastectomy, but the decision-making process in terms of risk-balancing and diagnosis influences satisfaction with self and surgery. It underlines the importance of preoperative management of expectations for patients undergoing risk-reducing procedures.
引用
- Kazzazi F, Haggie R, Forouhi P, et al. A comparison of patient satisfaction (using the BREAST-Q questionnaire) with bilateral breast reconstruction following risk-reducing or therapeutic mastectomy. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2018. PMID: 30025758. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2018.06.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。