影响因子的批判及其在整形与重建外科中的误用后果:影响因子的真实影响
本文评论影响因子的局限性,指出其高估大发行量期刊、低估小型专科期刊,虽然无完美期刊评价指标,但在选刊投稿、资源分配、资助或引用时,应同时权衡高影响因子大刊与低影响因子但有效的专科期刊的附加价值。
要点
- 影响因子高估大发行量期刊,低估小型专科期刊。
- 选刊投稿、资源分配、资助或引用时不应仅看影响因子。
- 应同时权衡高影响因子大刊与低影响因子专科期刊的附加价值。
核心结论
- 影响因子并非完美体系,其创建者也承认这一点。
- 影响因子高估大发行量期刊、低估小型专科期刊,评价期刊价值时需综合权衡。
主要发现
- 影响因子用于比较期刊引用数与发文数,但被指为不完美系统。
- 当前影响因子高估大发行量期刊重要性,低估小型更专业化期刊。
- 无指标能完美评估期刊价值,选刊或资源分配时需兼顾专科期刊附加价值。
临床怎么用
- 选刊投稿、资源分配、资助或引用时,不应仅依赖影响因子。
- 应同时考虑高影响因子大刊与低影响因子但有效的专科期刊的附加价值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The impact factor is used to compare the number of citations of a journal with its number of publications. Although first used to assess the significance of various journals, its very creator has stated that it is an imperfect system. Presently, the impact factor overvalues the importance of large-readership journals and undervalues that of smaller more specialized journals. Although no metric can serve as a perfect assessment of a journal's worth, it is vital when selecting journals for publication, resource allocation, funding, or citation to weigh not only the impact factor of a large-volume journal, but also the added value of lower impact factor but also effective specialized subspecialty journals.
引用
- Nair L, Adetayo OA. A Critique of the Impact Factor and Ramifications of Its Misuse in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery: The Real Impact of the Impact Factor. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2018. PMID: 30052555. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000004774
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。