区域烧伤中心空中救护车服务过度使用情况分析
该研究回顾性分析了2013年5月至2016年1月单中心直升机转运的68例烧伤患者,66%符合空中救护车标准。不适当分诊患者烧伤面积更小(%TBSA 4.8 vs 25.3,P<.001)、火焰烧伤更少(48 vs 82%,P=.007)、住院时间更短(平均8.2 vs 21.2天,P=.002)、住院手术更少(平均0.69 vs 2.57次,P=.006)、无急诊操作(0 vs 56%,P<.001)且无死亡(0 vs 9%,P<.001)。若23例不适当分诊患者改用地面转运,按2016年加州Medicare报销标准可节省106,370美元(人均节省4,624美元)。
要点
- 66%直升机转运烧伤患者符合空中救护车标准,不适当分诊者烧伤面积更小、住院时间更短、手术更少。
- 23例不适当分诊患者若地面转运可节省106,370美元(人均4,624美元)。
核心结论
- 多数情况下空中救护车使用适当,但不适当分诊比例显著,其成本应与效用权衡,相当比例患者未从空中转运中获益。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入2013年5月至2016年1月单中心直升机转运的全部烧伤患者68例。
主要发现
- 不适当分诊患者%TBSA 4.8 vs 25.3(P<.001)。
- 不适当分诊患者火焰烧伤48 vs 82%(P=.007)。
- 不适当分诊患者平均住院日8.2 vs 21.2天(P=.002)。
- 不适当分诊患者平均住院手术0.69 vs 2.57次(P=.006)。
- 不适当分诊患者急诊操作0 vs 56%(P<.001),死亡0 vs 9%(P<.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- 适当分诊依据文献衍生的严重度标准判定。
- 23例不适当分诊患者若地面转运,按2016年加州Medicare报销标准可节省106,370美元,人均节省4,624美元。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Air ambulances rapidly transport burn patients to regional centers, expediting treatment. However, limited guidelines on transport introduce the risk for inappropriate triage and overuse. Given the additional costs of air vs ground transport, evaluation of transportation use is prudent. A retrospective review of all burn patients transported by helicopter to a single burn center from May 2013 to January 2016 was performed. Data gathered included patient demographics, transfer origin, burn characteristics, and inpatient hospital stay. The primary outcome was appropriate triage based on literature-derived severity criteria. Secondary outcomes included independent predictors of emergent treatments and the cost of overuse. Sixty-eight patients were examined, of which 66% met air ambulance criteria. Inappropriately triaged patients sustained smaller burns (% TBSA 4.8 vs 25.3, P < .001), had fewer flame burns (48 vs 82%, P = .007), had decreased lengths of stay (mean days 8.2 vs 21.2, P = .002), underwent fewer inpatient surgeries (mean 0.69 vs 2.57, P = .006), received no emergent procedures (0 vs 56%, P < .001), and suffered no deaths (0 vs 9%, P < .001). Independent predictors of emergent procedures included transport for airway concern (odds ratio = 45.29, confidence interval = 2.49-825.21, P = .010) and % TBSA (odds ratio = 1.13, confidence interval = 1.02-1.27, P = .019). If the 23 inappropriately triaged patients had been transported by ground, a cost savings of $106,370 could have been realized using 2016 California Medicare reimbursements (per-patient savings of $4624). While appropriate in most circumstances, the cost of air ambulances should be weighed in light of their utility, as a significant proportion of patients did not benefit from air transport.
引用
- Chattopadhyay A, Sheckter CC, Long C, et al. Overuse of Air Ambulance Services at a Regional Burn Center. J Burn Care Res. 2018. PMID: 29901800. doi:10.1093/jbcr/irx028
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。