采用最佳实践策略提高纵向研究参与率:西北地区烧伤模型系统电话联系数据分析
作为多中心纵向患者报告结局研究的一部分,本中心随访率未持续达到80%的基准。2015年1月实施一套称为「最佳实践」的数据采集措施,比较实施前6个月与实施后6个月的成功率,并回顾实施后6个月手机通话记录。结果显示,在3个研究时间点中,有2个随访率改善;电话联系成功率仅为全部拨打电话的12%。
要点
- 实施「最佳实践」后,3个研究时间点中2个的随访率改善。
- 电话联系研究参与者的成功率仅为全部拨打电话的12%。
- 数据可用于研究者规划未来研究及论证人员投入与全职当量需求。
核心结论
- 研究人员的「最佳实践」使用使3个研究时间点中2个的随访率改善。
- 电话联系研究参与者的成功率仅为全部拨打电话的12%。
- 这些数据可供研究者在规划未来研究及论证人员投入与全职当量需求时使用。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心纵向患者报告结局研究的一部分,比较「最佳实践」实施前6个月与实施后6个月的随访成功率。
- 回顾实施后6个月的手机通话记录,分析通话特征、人口学代表、通话时机与通话成功情况。
- 手机记录回顾中尝试联系共98名受试者。
主要发现
- 「最佳实践」实施后,3个研究时间点中2个的随访率改善。
- 电话联系研究参与者的成功率为全部拨打电话的12%。
- 「成功通话」定义为通话时间超过5分钟且获取调查数据。
- 成功率比较的显著性设定为<0.05,采用双尾z检验。
关键数值与推荐
- 纵向研究随访的最低基准设定为80%。
- 「成功通话」定义为通话时间超过5分钟且获取调查数据。
- 成功率比较的显著性设定为<0.05,采用双尾z检验。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Successful acquisition of survey data in any longitudinal study is key to reducing bias and determining reliable, generalizable findings. As part of a multicenter longitudinal study of patient-reported outcomes, a minimum benchmark for follow-up was set at 80%. In review of our center's participation, we found this benchmark was not consistently met. Thus, we identified a set of actions for study personnel concerning data acquisition for subject surveys. These actions, termed Best Practices, were implemented in January 2015. The purpose of this review is to determine whether the Best Practices were associated with improved follow-up. A comparison of success rates for the 6-months prior to and following program implementation was made. In addition, cell phone records for the 6-month period following implementation were reviewed for call characteristics (e.g. minutes used, date, and time of call), demographic representation (call area code), call timing (day and time of week), and call success. A "successful call" was defined as a call time longer than 5 minutes with acquisition of survey data. For the cell phone review, we attempted to reach a total of 98 subjects. Table 1 outlines information gleaned from the review of records following implementation of the Best Practices. Table 2 outlines the success rates for the two time periods compared (significance set at < 0.05; two-tailed z-test). Use of the Best Practices by research personnel resulted in improved follow-up rates for 2 of 3 study time points. Of interest is the effort required to reach study participants by telephone with a success rate of only 12% of all calls made. These data provide information that can be used by investigators as they plan future research and require evidence to substantiate personnel effort and/or Full-Time-Equivalent (FTE) requirements.
引用
- Carrougher GJ, Muffley LA, Baker CP, et al. Use of Best Practice Strategies to Improve Longitudinal Study Participation: Analysis of Telephone Contact Data From the Northwest Regional Burn Model System. J Burn Care Res. 2018. PMID: 29931107. doi:10.1093/jbcr/irx050
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。