烧伤外科医生与姑息治疗医生对老年烧伤患者治疗目标界定的态度调查
多中心联盟指导委员会开发13项调查工具,经电子方式发放给美国烧伤协会与美国临终关怀与姑息医学学会的活跃医师会员,共45名烧伤外科医生(7.3%)和244名姑息治疗专家(5.7%)回应。姑息治疗医生在熟悉治疗目标讨论、与普通人交谈舒适度、高质量培训报告、ICU需要更多姑息专家及讨论兴趣方面均高于烧伤外科医生。两组均认为自己进行讨论优于对方所认为的水平,烧伤外科医生倾向主导团队讨论而姑息专家倾向共同主导,两组均同意讨论应在入院72小时内进行。
要点
- 姑息治疗医生比烧伤外科医生更熟悉治疗目标讨论且报告更高质量培训。
- 烧伤外科医生倾向主导团队讨论,姑息专家倾向共同主导讨论。
- 两组均同意治疗目标讨论应在入院72小时内进行。
核心结论
- 两组均认为自己进行老年烧伤患者治疗目标讨论优于对方所认为的水平,导致对最佳讨论主导方式看法分歧。
研究设计与样本
- 由致力于受伤老年患者姑息治疗的多中心联盟指导委员会开发13项调查工具,经与该联盟无关的烧伤外科医生和姑息治疗专家β测试后定稿。
- 定稿工具以电子方式发放给美国烧伤协会和美国临终关怀与姑息医学学会的活跃医师会员。
- 45名烧伤外科医生(7.3%)和244名姑息治疗专家(5.7%)回应。
主要发现
- 姑息治疗医生比烧伤外科医生更熟悉治疗目标讨论、更舒适与普通人交谈、更可能报告高质量培训、更认为ICU需要更多姑息专家、对进行讨论更有兴趣。
- 两组均认为自己进行讨论优于对方所认为的水平。
- 烧伤外科医生倾向主导团队讨论,姑息专家倾向共同主导讨论。
- 两组均同意讨论应在入院72小时内进行。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Palliative care specialists (PCS) and burn surgeons (BS) were surveyed regarding: 1) importance of goals of care (GoC) conversations for burned seniors; 2) confidence in their own specialty's ability to conduct these conversations; and 3) confidence in the ability of the other specialty to do so. A 13-item survey was developed by the steering committee of a multicenter consortium dedicated to palliative care in the injured geriatric patient and beta-tested by BS and PCS unaffiliated with the consortium. The finalized instrument was electronically circulated to active physician members of the American Burn Association and American Academy for Hospice and Palliative Medicine. Forty-five BS (7.3%) and 244 PCS (5.7%) responded. Palliative physicians rated being more familiar with GoC, were more comfortable having a discussion with laypeople, were more likely to have reported high-quality training in performing conversations, believed more palliative specialists were needed in intensive care units, and had more interest in conducting conversations relative to BS. Both groups believed themselves to perform GoC discussions better than the other specialty perceived them to do so. BS favored leading team discussions, whereas palliative specialists preferred jointly led discussions. Both groups agreed that discussions should occur within 72 hours of admission. Both groups believe themselves to conduct GoC discussions for burned seniors better than the other specialty perceived them to do so, which led to disparate views on perceptions for the optimal leadership of these discussions.
引用
- Cunningham HB, Scielzo SA, Nakonezny PA, et al. Burn Surgeon and Palliative Care Physician Attitudes Regarding Goals of Care Delineation for Burned Geriatric Patients. J Burn Care Res. 2018. PMID: 29771351. doi:10.1093/jbcr/iry027
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。