首席美容门诊13年结局分析
该研究回顾性分析13年间首席美容门诊326例患者、714例美容手术的并发症与修复率,并与文献比较;同时对26名前首席住院医师进行电子调查。结果显示大手术并发症率6.1%、修复率12.8%,均在文献参考范围内;调查应答率77%,所有应答者认为该门诊对住院医师教育和未来执业有积极影响。
要点
- 大手术并发症率6.1%、修复率12.8%,均在文献参考范围内。
- 调查应答率77%,所有应答者认为首席门诊对教育和未来执业有积极影响。
- 90%应答者对拉皮、身体塑形和美容乳房手术感到「非常自如」。
核心结论
- 首席住院医师美容门诊可提供并发症率和修复率在文献可接受范围内的结果,并为住院医师提供宝贵经验,使其对关键美容手术操作具有高舒适度。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性病历审查,纳入13年间首席美容门诊326例患者、714例美容手术,记录并发症与修复率。
- 另对26名前首席住院医师发送电子调查,了解其经历与印象。
主要发现
- 共对326例患者实施713例手术,患者年龄5至75岁(平均40.8岁),平均随访76.2天,平均每年56例手术。
- 714例手术中,小手术136例,无并发症,1例美容注射修复;大手术578例,总体并发症率6.1%,修复率12.8%。
- 各手术的并发症率与修复率进一步分析并与文献比较,并发症率落在文献报告的参考范围内。
- 调查应答率77%,所有应答者报告首席门诊对其住院医师教育和未来执业有积极影响。
- 90%应答者对拉皮、身体塑形和美容乳房手术感到「非常自如」;无应答者完成后续美容 fellowship,60%表示首席门诊的积极体验促使其决定不追求美容 fellowship。
临床怎么用
- 作者结论认为首席住院医师美容门诊可提供并发症率和修复率在文献可接受范围内的结果,并提供宝贵经验使住院医师对关键美容手术操作具有高舒适度。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Adequate resident training in aesthetic surgery has become increasingly important with rising demand. Chief resident aesthetic clinics allow hands on experience with an appropriate amount of autonomy. The purpose of this study was to compare resident cosmetic clinic outcomes to those reported in the literature. Furthermore, we sought to assess how effective these clinics can be in preparing residents in performing common aesthetic surgery procedures. METHOD: A retrospective chart review of 326 patients and 714 aesthetic procedures in our chief cosmetic clinic over a 13-year period was performed, and complication and revision rates were recorded. In addition, an electronic survey was sent to 26 prior chief residents regarding their experience and impressions of the chief resident aesthetic clinic. RESULT: A total of 713 procedures were performed on 326 patients. Patient ages ranged from 5 to 75 years old (mean, 40.8 years old) with a mean follow-up of 76.2 days. On average, there were 56 procedures performed per year. Of the 714 total procedures performed, there were 136 minor procedures and 578 major procedures. Of the 136 minor procedures, there were no complications and there was 1 revision of a cosmetic injection. Of the 578 major procedures, the overall complication rate was 6.1% and the revision rate was 12.8%. Complication and revision rates for each individual surgery were further analyzed and compared with the literature. The complication rates for these procedures fell within the reference ranges reported. In regards to the chief resident survey, there was a 77% response rate. All respondents reported that the chief resident clinic positively affected their residency education and future practice. Ninety percent of respondents felt "very comfortable" performing facelifts, body contouring, and aesthetic breast surgery. No respondents completed a subsequent cosmetic fellowship, and 60% stated that their positive experience in chief clinic contributed to their decision not to pursue a cosmetic fellowship. CONCLUSIONS: Chief resident clinics can provide results with acceptable complication and revision rates that fall within the acceptable ranges in the literature. In addition, it provides a valuable experience that leaves residents with high comfort levels in performing key procedures in aesthetic surgery.
引用
- Walker NJ, Crantford JC, Rudolph MA, et al. Outcomes Analysis of Chief Cosmetic Clinic Over 13 Years. Ann Plast Surg. 2018. PMID: 29664825. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000001443
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。