自体脂肪移植乳房重建的验证结局:VOGUE研究——面向研究与审计的核心结局集开发
VOGUE研究旨在为乳腺癌术后自体脂肪移植乳房重建建立核心结局集。研究预先发表方案,基于前期工作生成结局清单并分为肿瘤学、临床、美学与功能、患者报告、流程及影像学六个域,对78名利益相关者进行德尔菲共识调查。首轮55人(71%)完成,13个结局中9个达成共识,因结果清晰且无新增结局建议,未进行后续轮次。
要点
- VOGUE研究开发了自体脂肪移植乳房重建的核心结局集。
- 首轮德尔菲调查55/78名参与者(71%)完成,13个结局中9个达成共识。
- 作者希望临床医生用该核心结局集审计实践,研究者将其纳入研究设计与报告。
核心结论
- VOGUE研究为自体脂肪移植这一活跃的研究前沿与临床领域开发了亟需的核心结局集。
- 作者希望临床医生使用该核心结局集审计其实践,研究者将其纳入研究设计与自体脂肪移植结局的报告。
- 作者鼓励期刊与外科协会认可并鼓励使用该核心结局集,以帮助提升辩论、论述与文献的科学质量。
研究设计与样本
- 作者预先发表了研究方案。
- 基于其前期工作生成的结局清单开展了一项针对关键利益相关者的德尔菲共识调查。
- 结局被分为六个域:肿瘤学、临床、美学与功能、患者报告、流程及影像学。
主要发现
- 首轮中78名参与者中的55名(71%)完成了德尔菲共识调查。
- 13个结局中有9个达成共识。
- 结果的清晰性及缺乏额外建议的结局使进一步轮次被认为不必要。
关键数值与推荐
- 首轮德尔菲调查完成率为55/78(71%)。
- 13个结局中9个达成共识。
- 结局分为六个域:肿瘤学、临床、美学与功能、患者报告、流程及影像学。
临床怎么用
- 作者希望临床医生使用该核心结局集审计其实践。
- 作者希望研究者将该核心结局集纳入研究设计及自体脂肪移植结局的报告。
- 作者鼓励期刊与外科协会认可并鼓励使用该核心结局集。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Autologous fat grafting is an important part of the reconstructive surgeon's toolbox when treating women affected by breast cancer and subsequent tumor extirpation. The debate over safety and efficacy of autologous fat grafting continues within the literature. However, work performed by the authors' group has shown significant heterogeneity in outcome reporting. Core outcome sets have been shown to reduce heterogeneity in outcome reporting. The authors' goal was to develop a core outcome set for autologous fat grafting in breast reconstruction. METHODS: The authors published their protocol a priori. A Delphi consensus exercise among key stakeholders was conducted using a list of outcomes generated from their previous work. These outcomes were divided into six domains: oncologic, clinical, aesthetic and functional, patient-reported, process, and radiologic. RESULTS: In the first round, 55 of 78 participants (71 percent) completed the Delphi consensus exercise. Consensus was reached on nine of the 13 outcomes. The clarity of the results and lack of additional suggested outcomes deemed further rounds to be unnecessary. CONCLUSIONS: The VOGUE Study has led to the development of a much-needed core outcome set in the active research front and clinical area of autologous fat grafting. The authors hope that clinicians will use this core outcome set to audit their practice, and that researchers will implement these outcomes in their study design and reporting of autologous fat grafting outcomes. The authors encourage journals and surgical societies to endorse and encourage use of this core outcome set to help refine the scientific quality of the debate, the discourse, and the literature. CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic, V.
引用
- Agha RA, Pidgeon TE, Borrelli MR, et al. Validated Outcomes in the Grafting of Autologous Fat to the Breast: The VOGUE Study. Development of a Core Outcome Set for Research and Audit. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2018. PMID: 29697603. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000004273
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。