文献速递显微修复重建

头颈显微外科系统综述的质量:整形外科与耳鼻喉科的视角

The Quality of Systematic Reviews in Head and Neck Microsurgery: A Perspective from Plastic Surgery and Otolaryngology.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Plast Surg · 2018-01-01

该研究通过检索PubMed和Scopus评估13种高影响力外科期刊上头颈显微外科系统综述的方法学质量,最终纳入19篇(耳鼻喉科10篇、整形外科9篇),中位AMSTAR评分耳鼻喉科8分、整形外科7分、总体8分,反映质量「中等至良好」,且整形外科的AMSTAR评分和发表数量从2014年到2016年稳步上升。

要点

  • 最终纳入19篇头颈显微外科系统综述,耳鼻喉科10篇、整形外科9篇。
  • 中位AMSTAR评分:耳鼻喉科8分、整形外科7分、总体8分,质量「中等至良好」。
  • 整形外科的AMSTAR评分和系统综述数量从2014年到2016年稳步上升,耳鼻喉科自2010年以来相对稳定。

核心结论

  • 本综述显示系统综述发表呈增多趋势,整形外科发表系统综述数量和质量增加表明对更高证据等级的认识以及显微外科兴趣和进展。
  • 鉴于这些趋势,熟悉AMSTAR等质量评估指南对于为构建相关价值导向质量措施提供基础仍然重要。

研究设计与样本

  • 通过检索PubMed和Scopus对13种高影响力外科期刊上发表的显微外科系统综述进行评估,两名作者独立检索、筛选合格性并提取数据,分歧通过讨论和共识解决,使用AMSTAR标准评估方法学质量。

主要发现

  • 初始数据库检索获得166篇文章,去除重复、筛选标题和摘要后剩余26篇进行全文审查,7篇不聚焦头颈显微外科被进一步排除,最终19篇系统综述纳入最终分析。
  • 19篇中耳鼻喉科发表10篇系统综述,整形外科发表9篇。
  • 中位AMSTAR评分耳鼻喉科为8分,整形外科为7分,总体为8分,反映「中等至良好」质量。
  • 头颈显微外科系统综述数量随时间显著增加。
  • 整形外科发表的AMSTAR评分和系统综述数量从2014年到2016年稳步上升,而耳鼻喉科发表的自2010年以来保持相对稳定。

关键数值与推荐

  • 中位AMSTAR评分:耳鼻喉科8分,整形外科7分,总体8分,反映「中等至良好」质量。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: In recent years, there has been a push to publish higher level of evidence studies in medicine, particularly in plastic surgery. Well-conducted systematic reviews are considered the strongest level of evidence in medicine, recently becoming the key process indicators for quality delivery. A varying quality of systematic reviews, however, has led to concerns of their validity in clinical decision-making. We perform a quality analysis of systematic reviews published in head and neck microsurgery by the surgical specialties of plastic surgery and otolaryngology. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An evaluation of systematic reviews published on microsurgery in 13 high-impact surgical journals was conducted by searching PubMed and Scopus. Two authors independently performed searches, screened for eligibility, and extracted data from included articles. Discrepancies were resolved by discussion and consensus. Assessment of Multiple Systematic Reviews (AMSTAR) criteria were used to assess methodological quality. RESULTS: The initial database search retrieved 166 articles. After removing duplicates, screening titles and abstracts, 26 articles remained for full text review. Seven did not focus on head and neck microsurgery and were further excluded, leaving 19 systematic reviews for final analysis. Of those, 10 systematic reviews were published by otolaryngology, and 9 were published by plastic surgery. Median AMSTAR score was 8 for otolaryngology, 7 for plastic surgery, and 8 overall, reflecting "fair to good" quality. The number of systematic reviews on head and neck microsurgery markedly increased over time. Of note, both the AMSTAR score and the number of systematic reviews published by plastic surgery have steadily increased from 2014 to 2016, whereas those published by otolaryngology have remained relatively stable since 2010. CONCLUSIONS: Our review shows a trend toward publishing more systematic reviews. The increasing quantity and quality of systematic reviews published by plastic surgeons indicates recognition in the need for higher levels of evidence in plastic surgery, as well as growing interest and advances in microsurgery. Given these trends, familiarity with quality assessment guidelines, such as AMSTAR, will remain important in providing a basis for building relevant value-based quality measures.

来源:Ann Plast Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Sun BJ, Tijerina J, Nazerali RS, et al. The Quality of Systematic Reviews in Head and Neck Microsurgery: A Perspective from Plastic Surgery and Otolaryngology. Ann Plast Surg. 2018. PMID: 29489536. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000001384

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。