烧伤对男性力量和有氧运动能力的影响可能具有年龄依赖性
本研究将40例烧伤男童与35例烧伤成年男性按烧伤面积和住院时间匹配,比较出院时及有氧与抗阻训练后的力量和有氧能力。两组出院时峰值扭矩和峰值摄氧量均低于同龄常模,男童力量低于成年男性,成年男性有氧能力改善更明显。
要点
- 烧伤男童与成年男性按烧伤面积和住院时长匹配后比较运动能力。
- 出院时两组峰值扭矩和峰值摄氧量均低于同龄常模。
- 抗阻训练后成年男性有氧能力改善幅度大于男童。
核心结论
- 出院时及抗阻训练后,烧伤对力量和有氧运动能力的影响可能具有年龄依赖性,评估运动方案疗效和进展时应考虑年龄因素。
研究设计与样本
- 将40例烧伤男童(12±4岁,149±20 cm,46±18 kg)与35例烧伤成年男性(33±9岁,174±10 cm,84±16 kg)按烧伤面积和住院时长匹配进行比较。
- 力量(峰值扭矩)和有氧适能(峰值摄氧量)按去脂体重每千克标准化后进行组间比较。
- 每组还与出院时及有氧与抗阻训练项目后的年龄性别匹配常模值比较,采用双因素协方差分析评估组别与时间的交互及主效应。
主要发现
- 男童与成年男性抗阻训练前后总去脂体重(约4%)和脂肪量(7%)增加相似(各P≤.008)。
- 出院时两组峰值扭矩(男童为常模值的36%,成年男性为51%)和峰值摄氧量(男童44%,成年男性59%)均低于年龄性别匹配常模值(各P≤.0001)。
- 出院时及抗阻训练后男童力量比成年男性低13-15%(组别主效应P<.0001)。
- 抗阻训练后成年男性有氧适能改善19%,男童改善10%(组别×时间交互P=.011)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Whether burn injury affects boys and men differently is currently unknown. To test the hypothesis that burned boys have lower exercise capacity and exercise training-induced responses compared with burned men, 40 young boys (12 ± 4 years, 149 ± 20 cm, 46 ± 18 kg) were matched to 35 adult men (33 ± 9 years, 174 ± 10 cm, 84 ± 16 kg) based on extent of burn injury (total body surface area burned, boys 46 ± 14% vs men 47 ± 30, P = .85) and length of hospital stay (boys 33 ± 23 vs men 41 ± 32 days, P = .23). Strength (peak torque) and cardiorespiratory fitness (peak VO2) were normalized to kg of lean body mass for group comparisons. Each group was also compared with normative age-sex matched values at discharge and after an aerobic and resistance exercise training (RET) program. A two-way factorial analysis of covariance assessed interaction and main effects of group and time. We found that boys and men showed similar pre-RET to post-RET increases in total lean (~4%) and fat (7%) mass (each P ≤ .008). Both groups had lower age-sex matched norm values at discharge for peak torque (boys 36%; men 51% of normative values) and peak VO2 (boys: 44; men: 59%; each P ≤ .0001). Boys strength were 13-15 per cent lower than men at discharge and after RET (main effect for group, P < .0001). Cardiorespiratory fitness improved to a greater extent in men (19%) compared with boys (10%) after the RET (group × time interaction, P = .011). These results show that at discharge and after RET, burn injury may have age-dependent effects and should be considered when evaluating efficacy and progress of the exercise program.
引用
- Rivas E, Sanchez K, Cambiaso-Daniel J, et al. Burn Injury May Have Age-Dependent Effects on Strength and Aerobic Exercise Capacity in Males. J Burn Care Res. 2018. PMID: 29596612. doi:10.1093/jbcr/irx057
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。