假体隆乳与乳房上提固定联合假体隆乳术后生活质量比较研究
该研究在Oslo整形外科诊所对61例假体隆乳(BI组)和37例乳房上提固定联合假体隆乳(AM组)患者进行匿名47题生活质量问卷调查,比较两组患者特征与生活质量。BI组在整体美容效果、乳房体积及多项心理社会维度的满意度显著高于AM组,AM组在形态、瘢痕、对称性及乳头乳晕复合体方面报告了显著不满。
要点
- BI组在整体美容效果、增大效果和乳房体积的满意度显著高于AM组(93.4%、90.2%、80% vs 69.4%、70.2%、67%)。
- BI组在形态、瘢痕和对称性的满意度也显著高于AM组(90.1% vs 63.9%、70.6% vs 40.5%、83.6% vs 54.0%)。
- AM组患者可能对手术有不同于BI组的期望,并在形态、瘢痕、对称性和乳头乳晕复合体方面报告了显著不满。
核心结论
- 两组患者均非刻板印象人群,两组手术动机均以美容为主。
- BI组患者对美学效果及多项心理社会生活质量维度的满意度显著更高。
- AM组患者可能对手术有不同期望,并在形态、瘢痕、对称性和乳头乳晕复合体方面报告了显著不满。
研究设计与样本
- 在Oslo整形外科诊所开展的一项比较性匿名研究,向患者发放47题生活质量问卷。
- 2005年至2009年间接受假体隆乳的61例患者(BI组)和接受乳房上提固定联合假体隆乳的37例患者(AM组)完成应答。
- 问卷通过QuestBack回邮系统处理并返回作者,采用统计学分析评估组间显著性。
主要发现
- BI组应答率为67%,AM组为88%;两组平均随访时间均为2.8年。
- BI组手术动机主要为美容(65%)和情感(48%),AM组主要为美容(78%)和身体(31%)。
- BI组在生活改变和感觉成为「完整」的人方面显著优于AM组(68.9% vs 40.5%和73.8% vs 40%)。
- BI组对整体美容效果、增大效果和乳房体积的满意度显著高于AM组(93.4%、90.2%、80% vs 69.4%、70.2%、67%)。
- BI组对形态、瘢痕和对称性的满意度显著高于AM组(90.1% vs 63.9%、70.6% vs 40.5%、83.6% vs 54.0%)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Research regarding quality of life (QoL) among women who have undergone breast aesthetic surgery is expanding. A comparative, anonymous study between the two main breast aesthetic procedures is needed. OBJECTIVES: The authors compared patient characteristics and aspects of QoL among women who underwent breast enlargement with implants (BI group) and those who underwent augmentation mastopexy (AM group). METHODS: Patients at the Oslo Plastic Surgery Clinic were given a 47-question survey to measure QoL. The survey was anonymous; 61 patients who received breast implants and 37 patients who underwent augmentation mastopexy between 2005 and 2009 responded. Answers were processed by a QuestBack return mail system and sent to the authors. Statistical analyses were performed to evaluate significance between the groups. RESULTS: The response rate was 67% in the BI group and 88% in the AM group. Mean follow-up time was 2.8 years in both groups. Motivation for surgery was primarily cosmetic (65%) and emotional (48%) in the BI group as well as cosmetic (78%) and physical (31%) in the AM group. The effects on psychosocial aspects were significant in the BI group regarding life changes and feeling like a "whole" person (68.9% vs 40.5% and 73.8% vs 40%). BI group also had a significantly higher satisfaction with overall cosmetic result, enlargement, and breast volume (93.4 %, 90.2%, 80% vs 69.4%, 70.2% vs 67% in AM group). Additionally, the BI group was more satisfied with shape, scar, and symmetry (90.1% vs 63.9%, 70.6% vs 40.5%, and 83.6% vs 54.0%, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: None of our patient groups were stereotypical and motivation for surgery was primarily cosmetic in both groups. BI patients were significantly more satisfied with the aesthetic outcome and the QoL of many psychosocial aspects. AM patients may have had different expectations than BI patients and a significant dissatisfaction was reported in shape, scarring, symmetry, and the nipple-areola complex.
引用
- Kalaaji A, Dreyer S, Brinkmann J, et al. Quality of Life After Breast Enlargement With Implants Versus Augmentation Mastopexy: A Comparative Study. Aesthet Surg J. 2018. PMID: 29481590. doi:10.1093/asj/sjy047
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。