学术产出的替代计量指标:整形与重建外科中Altmetric评分、Mendeley读者评分、引用次数与下载量之间的关系
该研究选取《Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery》2014至2015年被引次数最多的55篇文章,提取Altmetric评分、下载量、领域加权引用次数和Mendeley读者数,分析各指标间的相关性。结果显示Altmetric评分与Scopus引用次数无显著相关(p=0.58),引用次数与下载量(r=0.31,p=0.021)及Mendeley读者数(r=0.46,p=0.001)正相关,Mendeley读者数能高精度识别高被引文章(p=0.044)。作者认为Altmetric评分具有独特性,不应孤立使用;下载量是比引用次数更快速的出版影响力指标;Mendeley读者数也是有前景的替代指标。
要点
- Altmetric评分与Scopus引用次数无显著相关(p=0.58),与文章主题也无显著相关(p=0.63)。
- 引用次数与下载量正相关(r=0.31,p=0.021),与Mendeley读者数正相关(r=0.46,p=0.001)。
- Mendeley读者数能高精度识别高被引文章(p=0.044),但与Altmetric评分无直接关联(p=0.83)。
核心结论
- Altmetric评分具有独特性,不应孤立使用;下载量是比引用次数更快速的出版影响力指标;Mendeley读者数也是有前景的替代指标。
研究设计与样本
- 研究选取《Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery》2014至2015年被引次数最多的55篇文章,提取Altmetric评分、下载量、领域加权引用次数和Mendeley读者数,使用相关矩阵分析各评分间的正相关关系,并对排名最高的文章集中评估中心主题和统一评分方法。
主要发现
- 最高Altmetric评分为159,最高引用次数为52,最高下载量为41。
- Altmetric评分与Scopus引用次数无显著相关(p=0.58),与文章主题也无显著相关(p=0.63)。
- 引用次数与下载量正相关(r=0.31,p=0.021),与Mendeley读者数正相关(r=0.46,p=0.001)。
- Mendeley读者数在识别高被引文章方面表现出高精度(p=0.044),尽管与Altmetric评分无直接关联(p=0.83)。
关键数值与推荐
- 最高Altmetric评分为159,最高引用次数为52,最高下载量为41。
- Altmetric评分与Scopus引用次数无显著相关(p=0.58),与文章主题无显著相关(p=0.63)。
- 引用次数与下载量正相关(r=0.31,p=0.021),与Mendeley读者数正相关(r=0.46,p=0.001)。
- Mendeley读者数识别高被引文章的p=0.044,与Altmetric评分的p=0.83。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为Altmetric评分具有独特性,不应孤立使用;下载量是比引用次数更快速的出版影响力指标;Mendeley读者数也是有前景的替代指标。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The impact of scholarly output is typically measured by the number of citations and, more recently, downloads. Newer metrics have been developed to reflect digital dissemination of knowledge such as the Altmetric and Mendeley reader scores. This article examines the relationship among citations, download rates, Altmetric scores, and Mendeley reader scores in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery. METHODS: The authors accessed the 55 most-cited articles published in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery from 2014 to 2015. Altmetric scores, download rates, field-weighted citations, and Mendeley reader number were extracted. Correlation matrices were used to identify methodologies positively correlating between scores. The top-ranked articles were then collectively evaluated for central subject themes and unifying scoring methodologies. RESULTS: The highest Altmetric score obtained was 159, the greatest number of citations was 52, and the greatest number of downloads was 41. There was no apparent correlation between Altmetric scores and Scopus citations (p = 0.58) or article subject themes (p = 0.63). Citation was positively associated with download rates (r = 0.31, p = 0.021) and Mendeley reader number (r = 0.46, p = 0.001). Mendeley reader number demonstrated high precision in identifying top-ranked citation articles (p = 0.044) despite its lack of direct association with Altmetric score (p = 0.83). CONCLUSIONS: With the growing public desire for evidence-based publications, our study quantifies the unique nature of Altmetric score while discouraging its use in isolation. Download rates are a more rapid measure of publication impact compared with citation number. Mendeley readership is also promising as an alternative index.
引用
- Ruan QZ, Chen AD, Cohen JB, et al. Alternative Metrics of Scholarly Output: The Relationship among Altmetric Score, Mendeley Reader Score, Citations, and Downloads in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2018. PMID: 29481413. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000004128
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。