是时候放下手术刀了:对随机和非随机试验中烧伤削痂工具的系统综述
该研究系统检索CENTRAL、EMBASE和MEDLINE(1946-2017年),评估手术刀、水刀和酶解清创三种烧伤削痂方式的证据。共纳入18篇文章(n=7148),其中3项为随机对照试验,比较酶解制剂NexoBrid™或水刀Versajet™与手术标准治疗。两种方法均显示可保留有活力组织、允许上皮化自发愈合,从而显著减少削痂和自体移植需求。作者认为烧伤削痂方式的1级证据稀少,EDNX或Versajet™可考虑作为替代选择。
要点
- 急性烧伤削痂中保留真皮是获得良好愈合和瘢痕结局的关键。
- 共纳入18篇文章(n=7148),仅3项为随机对照试验。
- EDNX或Versajet™与手术标准治疗相比,均显著减少削痂和自体移植需求。
核心结论
- 烧伤削痂方式的1级证据稀少,尚无工具选择共识或与可能更优替代工具的稳健比较。
- 早期手术刀削痂仍常被视为最佳实践,但EDNX或Versajet™可考虑作为替代选择。
- 需要进一步随机对照试验,关注最终瘢痕结局并在现有证据内达成共识。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索CENTRAL、EMBASE和MEDLINE(1946-2017年),检索词包括debridement、burns、sharp、enzymatic、hydrosurgery。
- 纳入随机对照试验、非随机对照病例系列或试验,排除体外研究和非烧伤特异性研究。
- 共纳入18篇文章(n=7148),其中3项为随机对照试验。
- 主要方法学参数为干预或削痂疗效。
主要发现
- 3项随机对照试验涉及酶解制剂NexoBrid™(EDNX)或水刀Versajet™与手术标准治疗的比较。
- 两种方法均显示通过保留有活力组织、允许上皮化自发愈合,显著减少削痂和自体移植需求。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为EDNX或Versajet™可考虑作为替代选择。
- 作者认为需要进一步随机对照试验,关注最终瘢痕结局并在现有证据内达成共识。
局限性
- 烧伤削痂方式的1级证据稀少。
- 尚无工具选择共识或与可能更优替代工具的稳健比较。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Dermal preservation during acute burn excision is key to obtaining superior healing/scar outcomes, however, determining the most appropriate excision tool is an ongoing challenge. Novel tool development means the knife is no longer our only option, yet for the majority it remains the gold standard. This systematic review aims to evaluate evidence for burns excision approaches (knife/hydrosurgery/enzymatic). METHODS: CENTRAL, EMBASE, MEDLINE (1946-2017) were searched with MeSH terms: 'debridement', 'burns', 'sharp', 'enzymatic', 'hydrosurgery'. Relevant randomised control trials (RCTs)/non-randomised controlled case series/trials were extracted/analysed. In vitro/burn non-specific studies were excluded. Main methodological parameters were intervention/excision efficacy. RESULTS: Eighteen articles met inclusion criteria (n=7148): three were RCTs, involving comparator enzymatic (NexoBrid™ (EDNX)) or hydrosurgical (Versajet™) excision to surgical Standard of Care. Both showed statistically significant decreased need for excisional excision and auto-grafting by viable tissue preservation allowing spontaneous healing by epithelialisation. CONCLUSION: Level 1 Evidence comparing excision modalities for acute burns is sparse. Although early excision with a knife is still often considered best practice, there is no tool choice consensus or robust comparison with alternate, possibly superior, tools. EDNX or Versajet™ should be considered alternatively. Further RCTs are indicated, with regards final scar outcomes and to allow consensus within current evidence.
引用
- Edmondson SJ, Ali Jumabhoy I, Murray A, et al. Time to start putting down the knife: A systematic review of burns excision tools of randomised and non-randomised trials. Burns. 2018. PMID: 29456099. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2018.01.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。