严重烧伤儿童出院时运动能力及康复训练后适应均无性别差异
本研究将25名烧伤女童与26名烧伤男童按烧伤面积匹配,比较出院时及有氧和抗阻康复训练后的瘦体重、肌力和心肺适能。结果显示两组瘦体重变化均约11%、峰值扭矩均增加16%、峰值摄氧量均增加15%,性别间无显著差异;烧伤儿童运动时峰值摄氧量和峰值心率占非烧伤儿童的比例更高,提示需要烧伤特异性运动方案。
要点
- 烧伤女童与男童在出院时及康复训练后的瘦体重、肌力和心肺适能无显著性别差异。
- 两组康复训练后瘦体重变化约11%、峰值扭矩增加16%、峰值摄氧量增加15%。
- 烧伤儿童运动时峰值摄氧量和峰值心率占非烧伤儿童比例更高,提示需烧伤特异性运动方案。
核心结论
- 烧伤对严重烧伤儿童的瘦体重或运动能力无性别依赖性影响。
- 相对峰值摄氧量和峰值心率的差异提示需要烧伤特异性运动方案以提高康复训练效果。
研究设计与样本
- 将25名烧伤女童与26名烧伤男童按烧伤面积匹配,并设年龄性别匹配的非烧伤儿童对照(男26名、女25名)。
- 在出院时及有氧和抗阻康复训练后比较瘦体重、峰值扭矩和峰值摄氧量,并归一化为瘦体重公斤及年龄性别匹配非烧伤儿童的百分比。
主要发现
- 两组瘦体重变化均约11%,出院时为非烧伤儿童的87.3%(95%CI 82.2,92.3),康复训练后为92.8%(95%CI 87.2,98.3),时间主效应P<0.0001。
- 两组峰值扭矩均增加16%,出院时为年龄性别匹配非烧伤儿童的55.9%(95%CI 51.3,60.5),康复训练后为77.5%(95%CI 72.1,82.9),时间主效应P<0.0001。
- 两组峰值摄氧量均增加15%,出院时为年龄性别匹配非烧伤儿童的56.8%(95%CI 52.4,61.2),康复训练后为72.2%(95%CI 67.6,76.8),时间主效应P<0.0001。
- 烧伤儿童运动时峰值摄氧量和峰值心率占非烧伤儿童的比例更高(组×时间交互作用P<0.0001)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,相对峰值摄氧量和峰值心率的差异提示需要烧伤特异性运动方案以提高康复训练效果。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Females have a 50% increased risk of death from burn injury compared to males. However, whether exercise capacity and exercise induced training adaptations differ between burned boys and girls is unknown. This project tested the hypothesis that girls with burns have lower exercise capacity and different exercise induced training adaptations. METHODS: Twenty-five girls were matched to 26 boys (mean, 95%CI; years 13 [12,14], cm 151 [143,161], kg 54 [45,63]; each P>0.05) for burn injury (% total body surface area burn, 54 [45,62]; P=0.82). Lean body mass (LBM), strength (peak torque) and cardiorespiratory fitness (peak VO2) were normalized to kg LBM and compared as a percentage of age-sex matched non-burned children (n=26 boys, years 13 [12,14]; n=25 girls, years 13 [12,14]) at discharge (DC) and after aerobic and resistance rehabilitation exercise training (RET). RESULTS: Using a 2-way factorial ANOVA (group×time), we found both groups had similar 11% change in LBM (87.3% of non-burned values [82.2,92.3]) and after the RET (92.8% [87.2,98.3]; main effect, time P<0.0001). Peak torque increased similarly by 16% in both groups (% of age-sex matched non-burned DC, 55.9 [51.3,60.5]; after RET, 77.5 [72.1,82.9]; main effect, time P<0.0001). Likewise, peak VO2 increased in both groups by 15% (% of age-sex matched non-burned DC, 56.8 [52.4,61.2] to RET, 72.2 [67.6,76.8]; main effect, time; P<0.0001). Burned children exercise at greater percentage of their peak VO2 and peak HR compared to non-burned children (Interaction, group×time, P<0.0001). CONCLUSION: The burn injury does not have sex-dependent effects on LBM or exercise capacity in severely burn injured children. Differences in relative peak VO2 and peak HR suggest the need for burn specific exercise programs for improving the efficacy of a rehabilitation program.
引用
- Rivas E, Herndon DN, Chapa ML, et al. Children with severe burns display no sex differences in exercise capacity at hospital discharge or adaptation after exercise rehabilitation training. Burns. 2018. PMID: 29429746. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2018.01.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。