指南与共识烧伤创面修复美容整形

整形外科领袖共识:采用改良德尔菲技术确定加拿大整形外科住院医师培训的手术操作能力要求

Consensus of Leaders in Plastic Surgery: Identifying Procedural Competencies for Canadian Plastic Surgery Residency Training Using a Modified Delphi Technique.
指南 / 共识 · Plast Reconstr Surg · 2018-01-01

该研究采用在线多轮改良德尔菲共识法,邀请加拿大整形外科项目主任、加拿大整形外科学会执行委员会及同行提名专家,将288项手术操作能力归入核心与非核心的五类能力预期中,以80%同意率作为共识标准。经过三轮,达成共识的手术从101项(35%)增至199项(69%),最终共识分类包括154项核心必需、23项核心非必需、3项非核心体验和19项非核心专科培训。

要点

  • 288项手术跨13个领域,最终199项(69%)达80%共识。
  • 烧伤领域同意率最高,下肢领域同意率最低。
  • 最终分类:核心必需154项、核心非必需23项、非核心体验3项、非核心专科培训19项。

核心结论

  • 研究明确了整形外科专家认为对毕业生独立执业最重要的手术操作,该列表代表当前培训环境下专家意见的 snapshot,需随专业发展定期更新。

研究设计与样本

  • 在线多轮改良德尔菲共识研究,邀请加拿大整形外科项目主任、加拿大整形外科学会执行委员会及同行提名专家参与。
  • 三轮中将288项手术操作能力归入核心与非核心的五类预定类别,以80%同意率表示共识。
  • 邀请49名专家,37名回复(75.5%),31名参与(占回复者的83.8%)。

主要发现

  • 识别出跨13个领域的288项手术。
  • 达80%共识的手术从第一轮101项(35%)增至第二轮159项(55%),第三轮增至199项(69%)。
  • 烧伤领域同意率最高,下肢领域同意率最低。
  • 最终共识分类:核心必需154项、核心非必需23项、非核心体验3项、非核心专科培训19项。

关键数值与推荐

  • 以80%同意率作为共识标准。
  • 核心与非核心手术下预设五类能力预期类别。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性;作者指出该列表代表当前培训环境下专家意见的 snapshot,随专业发展需定期更新。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Transitioning to competency-based surgical training will require consensus regarding the scope of plastic surgery and expectations of operative ability for graduating residents. Identifying surgical procedures experts deemed most important in preparing graduates for independent practice (i.e., "core" procedures), and those that are less important or deemed more appropriate for fellowship training (i.e., "noncore" procedures), will focus instructional and assessment efforts. METHODS: Canadian plastic surgery program directors, the Canadian Society of Plastic Surgeons Executive Committee, and peer-nominated experts participated in an online, multiround, modified Delphi consensus exercise. Over three rounds, panelists were asked to sort 288 procedural competencies into five predetermined categories within core and noncore procedures, reflecting increasing expectations of ability. Eighty percent agreement was chosen to indicate consensus. RESULTS: Two hundred eighty-eight procedures spanning 13 domains were identified. Invitations were sent to 49 experts; 37 responded (75.5 percent), and 31 participated (83.8 percent of respondents). Procedures reaching 80 percent consensus increased from 101 (35 percent) during round 1, to 159 (55 percent) in round 2, and to 199 (69 percent) in round 3. The domain "burns" had the highest rate of agreement, whereas "lower extremity" had the lowest agreement. Final consensus categories included 154 core, essential; 23 core, nonessential; three noncore, experience; and 19 noncore, fellowship. CONCLUSIONS: This study provides clarity regarding which procedures plastic surgery experts deem most important for preparing graduates for independent practice. The list represents a snapshot of expert opinion regarding the current training environment. As our specialty grows and changes, this information will need to be periodically revisited.

来源:Plast Reconstr Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Knox ADC, Shih JG, Warren RJ, et al. Consensus of Leaders in Plastic Surgery: Identifying Procedural Competencies for Canadian Plastic Surgery Residency Training Using a Modified Delphi Technique. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2018. PMID: 29481415. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000004132

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。