鼻喉镜在面部烧伤患者上气道损伤初始评估中的作用
该回顾性研究分析了某区域烧伤中心2年内因面部烧伤行纤维鼻喉镜评估上气道损伤的患者。有症状组22例中14例喉镜阳性、7例(50%)插管;无症状组188例中58例(31%)喉镜有病理改变、仅2例(1%)插管。结论认为鼻喉镜在无症状患者中临床意义有限,全面病史和体格检查是识别需插管高危患者的最佳工具,但需前瞻性试验进一步研究。
要点
- 无症状面部烧伤患者鼻喉镜病理改变占31%,但仅1%因此改变处理。
- 有症状患者喉镜阳性者中仅50%实际插管,病理改变意义存疑。
- 阴性鼻喉镜可能帮助少数有症状患者避免插管。
核心结论
- 研究显示上气道损伤的症状体征与鼻喉镜所见存在差异,无症状患者中红斑或水肿的临床意义存疑,鼻喉镜在该组获益有限。
- 有症状且鼻喉镜显示气道损伤的患者中仅50%实际插管,其病理改变的意义也受质疑,但阴性鼻喉镜可能对少数有症状患者避免插管有益。
- 作者认为全面病史和体格检查是识别需插管的上气道损伤高危患者的最佳工具,但需前瞻性试验进一步研究以确定鼻喉镜的明确作用。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析某区域烧伤中心2年内所有因面部烧伤行纤维鼻喉镜评估上气道损伤的患者。
- 入组标准为面部烧伤、烟灰或碳质痰,无论致伤机制均行鼻喉镜;到院前已插管者排除。
- 有症状定义为呼吸困难、呼吸急促、低氧或颊黏膜明显烧伤;通过操作记录判定声门上/声门区损伤(红斑或水肿)。
主要发现
- 有症状组22例中14例喉镜阳性,其中7例(50%)插管。
- 无症状组188例中58例(31%)喉镜见红斑、水肿或碳质碎屑,仅2例(1%)插管,且均在2天内拔管。
- 130例无症状且鼻喉镜阴性者无一例插管。
- 无症状患者中30%鼻喉镜显示病理改变,但仅1%因此改变处理。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为全面病史和体格检查是识别需插管的上气道损伤高危患者的最佳工具。
- 作者指出鼻喉镜在无症状面部烧伤患者中获益有限,红斑或水肿的临床意义存疑。
- 作者认为阴性鼻喉镜可能对少数有症状患者避免插管有益。
局限性
- 作者指出需前瞻性试验进一步研究以确定鼻喉镜的明确作用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Upper airway injuries can be fatal in burn patients if not recognized, a scenario that causes a significant amount of anxiety for physicians providing initial assessment of burn patients. Early elective intubation is often performed; sometimes unnecessarily. However, some providers employ nasolaryngoscopy for patients presenting with facial burns or signs/symptoms of upper airway injury in order to assess the need for intubation, but this practice is not considered standard of care and may also be unnecessary. Evidence is currently lacking about the utility of nasolaryngoscopy as an adjuvant assessment during evaluation of potential upper airway burn injuries. The objective of this study was to determine if nasolaryngoscopy provides additional information to the history and physical in making the decision to electively intubate patients with facial burns. METHODS: This study was a retrospective analysis of all patients who underwent fiberoptic nasolaryngoscopy after facial burn injury to evaluate for upper airway injury associated with burns over a 2 year period at a regional burn center. During this time period, all patients who presented with facial burns, soot, or carbonaceous sputum underwent nasolaryngoscopy to look for upper airway injury regardless of mechanism of injury. Patients intubated prior to arrival were excluded from the study. Patients were considered to have signs/symptoms of airway injury (symptomatic) if they presented with dyspnea, tachypnea, hypoxia, or significant burns to buccal mucosa. Procedure notes were used to determine if supraglottic/glottic injury (erythema or edema) was present on nasolaryngoscopy. Presence of pathologic changes and whether they led to intubation were evaluated in the asymptomatic and the symptomatic groups of patients. Select individual records were inspected further to help determine if the nasolaryngoscopy findings altered management plans and if intubation was ultimately necessary based upon the presence or absence of a cuff leak and the duration of intubation. RESULTS: Twenty-two patients were symptomatic upon presentation, 14 of which had positive findings on laryngoscopy and 7 (50%) were intubated. One-hundred and eighty-eight patients were asymptomatic, 58 (31%) of which had either erythema or edema or carbonaceous debris on nasolaryngoscopy, and only 2 (1%) were intubated. These patients were both extubated within two days. None of the 130 asymptomatic patients with negative nasolaryngoscopy were intubated. CONCLUSIONS: This study showed disparity between signs and symptoms of airway injury and nasolaryngoscopy findings. Asymptomatic patients showed pathologic changes in 30% of scopes, but this finding only changed management 1% of the time. Furthermore, the two patients in this group were extubated quickly, suggesting they may have been suitable for observation without intubation. These results indicate that the presence of erythema or edema is of questionable clinical significance in asymptomatic patients and nasolaryngoscopy is of limited benefit in this group. Only 50% of the symptomatic patients with airway injury evident on nasolaryngoscopy were actually intubated, also bringing into question the significance of the pathologic changes in this group. However, negative nasolaryngoscopy may have had some benefit in preventing intubation in a few, select symptomatic patients. This study suggests that a thorough history and physical is the best tool to identify patients at higher risk of upper airway injury who need intubation, but this should be further studied in prospective trials to determine the definitive role of nasolaryngoscopy.
引用
- Freno D, Sahawneh J, Harrison S, et al. Determining the role of nasolaryngoscopy in the initial evaluation for upper airway injury in patients with facial burns. Burns. 2017. PMID: 29122412. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2017.09.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。