激光多普勒成像与热成像评估烧伤深度的前瞻性对比评价研究
该前瞻性对比研究纳入16例烧伤患者共52个感兴趣区,在烧伤后第1天和第3天用激光多普勒成像、热成像、照片临床评估和实时临床评估四种方法判断烧伤深度,以21天内创面闭合为结局。结果显示第3天各方法准确性均高于第0天,激光多普勒成像准确性为92.3%,高于热成像的71.2%和照片临床评估的71.6%,实时临床检查准确性为88.5%;热成像扫描速度显著快于激光多普勒成像。
要点
- 烧伤后第3天评估准确性高于第0天,激光多普勒成像第3天准确性达92.3%。
- 激光多普勒成像准确性高于热成像(第3天92.3% vs 71.2%)和照片临床评估(71.6%)。
- 热成像扫描时间显著快于激光多普勒成像,但诊断准确性较低。
核心结论
- 激光多普勒成像在烧伤深度诊断准确性上优于热成像,可能因热成像易受环境因素影响。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性对比评价研究,纳入16例烧伤患者共52个感兴趣区。
- 烧伤深度用激光多普勒成像、热成像、照片临床评估和实时临床评估四种方法在烧伤后第1天和第3天判定。
- 以激光多普勒成像通量和ΔT值预测结局(21天内创面闭合)。
- 照片临床评估由4名设盲烧伤外科医生完成。
主要发现
- 烧伤后第0天和第3天激光多普勒成像准确性分别为80.8%和92.3%。
- 烧伤后第0天和第3天热成像准确性分别为55.8%和71.2%。
- 烧伤后第0天和第3天照片临床评估准确性分别为62.5%和71.6%。
- 实时临床检查准确性为88.5%。
- 热成像扫描时间显著快于激光多普勒成像。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The accurate assessment of burn depth is challenging but crucial for surgical excision and tissue preservation. Laser Doppler Imaging (LDI) has gained increasing acceptance as a tool to aid depth assessment but its adoption is hampered by high costs, long scan times and limited portability. Thermal imaging is touted as a suitable alternative however few comparison studies have been done. METHODS: Sixteen burn patients with 52 regions of interests were analysed. Burn depth was determined using four methods LDI, thermal imaging, photographic and real-time clinical evaluation at day 1 and day 3. LDI flux and Delta T values were used for the prediction of outcomes (wound closure in <21 days). Photographic clinical evaluation of burn depth was performed by 4 blinded burn surgeons. RESULTS: Accuracy of assessment methods were greater on post burn day 3 compared to day 0. Accuracies of LDI on post burn day 0 and 3 were 80.8% and 92.3% compared to 55.8% and 71.2% for thermal imaging and 62.5% and 71.6% for photographic clinical assessment. Real-time clinical examination had an accuracy of 88.5%. Thermal imaging scan times were significantly faster compared to LDI. DISCUSSION: LDI outperforms thermal imaging in terms of diagnostic accuracy of burn depth likely due to the susceptibility of thermal imaging to environmental factors.
引用
- Wearn C, Lee KC, Hardwicke J, et al. Prospective comparative evaluation study of Laser Doppler Imaging and thermal imaging in the assessment of burn depth. Burns. 2017. PMID: 29032974. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2017.08.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。