鼻中隔延伸移植物与双层耳廓软骨延伸移植物鼻尖成形术的比较研究
该研究比较了基于L形鼻中隔支架的鼻中隔延伸移植物与基于鼻尖全鼻中隔的双层耳廓软骨移植物在鼻尖突出度和旋转控制方面的差异。纳入2014年3月至2016年7月间27例纯美容原因行鼻尖成形术的患者,A组14例行鼻中隔延伸移植物,B组13例行双层耳廓软骨移植物。两组鼻尖突出度比率即刻分别达到61%和74%,术后维持,复发率分别为39%和26%,两组稳定性相似(p=0.722)。
要点
- A组14例行鼻中隔延伸移植物,B组13例行双层耳廓软骨移植物。
- 鼻尖突出度比率变化:A组61% vs B组74%,术后维持,p=0.722。
- 复发比率:A组39% vs B组26%,两组稳定性相似。
核心结论
- 鼻中隔延伸移植物与双层耳廓软骨移植物两种鼻尖成形术在稳定性方面相似。
- 作者认为,鉴于双层耳廓软骨移植物可保留鼻中隔支撑,该技术可能成为鼻整形术的有效且安全的替代选择。
研究设计与样本
- 比较性研究,纳入2014年3月至2016年7月间因纯美容原因行鼻尖成形术的27例连续患者。
- A组14例行基于L形鼻中隔支架的鼻中隔延伸移植物手术,B组13例行基于鼻尖全鼻中隔的双层耳廓软骨移植物手术。
- 通过临床摄影分析术前(时间0)、术后即刻(时间1,平均术后2周)和术后(时间2,平均术后7个月)的鼻尖突出度和鼻小柱唇角。
主要发现
- 鼻尖突出度比率变化:A组即刻达到61% vs B组74%,术后维持(时间2 vs 时间0除以时间1 vs 时间0),两组比较p=0.722。
- 该技术的复发比率:A组39% vs B组26%。
关键数值与推荐
- 鼻尖突出度比率变化:A组61% vs B组74%(p=0.722)。
- 复发比率:A组39% vs B组26%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The septal extension graft is currently the most commonly used primary and secondary rhinoplasty technique in Asia because it provides maximal tip projection and rotational controllability. The authors compared the tip projection amount and rotational controllability of the tip support between the septal extension graft based on the L-strut septum and double-layer conchal cartilage graft based on the full septum at the nasal tip. METHODS: Twenty-seven consecutive patients who underwent nasal tip plasty with the septal extension graft or double-layer conchal cartilage graft for purely aesthetic reasons between March of 2014 and July of 2016 were included. The nasal tip projection and columellar labial angle preoperatively (time 0), immediately postoperatively (time 1, an average of 2 weeks after the operation), and postoperatively (time 2, an average of 7 months after the operation) were analyzed with clinical photography. RESULTS: Fourteen patients (group A) underwent septal extension graft surgery and 13 (group B) underwent double-layer conchal cartilage graft surgery. Changes of 61 and 74 percent in tip projection ratio were immediately achieved and were maintained after surgery for groups A and B, respectively (time 2 versus time 0 dividing time 1 versus time 0; p = 0.722 for groups A and B). Therefore, the relapse ratio of this technique was 39 and 26 percent for groups A and B, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: This comparative study between the septal extension graft and double-layer conchal cartilage graft showed that both nasal tip plasties are similar in terms of stability. Considering the fact that the double-layer conchal cartilage graft could preserve septal support, this technique could become an effective and safe alternative option for rhinoplasty. CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic, III.
引用
- Suh YC, Jeong WS, Choi JW, et al. Septum-Based Nasal Tip Plasty: A Comparative Study between Septal Extension Graft and Double-Layered Conchal Cartilage Extension Graft. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2018. PMID: 28915210. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000003920
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。