激光多普勒成像与临床评估在区分浅二度与深二度烧伤创面中的比较
研究比较激光多普勒成像(LDI)与临床评估区分浅二度与深二度烧伤的准确性,纳入34例患者共92处创面,伤后5天内就诊且烧伤面积小于40%。以第21天愈合为金标准,LDI诊断准确率90.21%、临床评估81.52%,LDI预测准确性优于临床评估。
要点
- LDI诊断准确率90.21%,临床评估81.52%,LDI优于临床评估。
- LDI敏感性92.75%,临床评估81%;两者特异性均为82%。
- LDI阳性预测值94%、阴性预测值79%,临床评估分别为93%和59%。
核心结论
- LDI对创面愈合的预测准确性优于临床评估,以21天愈合为金标准。
- LDI可作为临床评估的可靠、可行且具成本效益的替代方法。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入34例患者共92处创面,就诊时间在伤后5天内,烧伤面积小于40%。
- 排除不稳定患者、孕妇及死亡患者。
- 创面同时进行临床评估与LDI检查,由互不知晓对方结果的整形外科医生完成。
- 第21天由同一批整形外科医生再次评估创面愈合情况,并与初始LDI及临床评估结果进行相关性分析。
主要发现
- 临床评估正确识别75处创面深度,LDI正确识别83处,诊断准确率分别为81.52%和90.21%。
- 临床评估敏感性81%,LDI敏感性92.75%;两者特异性均为82%。
- 临床评估阳性预测值93%,LDI阳性预测值94%。
- 临床评估阴性预测值59%,LDI阴性预测值79%。
关键数值与推荐
- 临床评估参数包括创面外观、颜色、是否变白、疼痛及毛囊脱落情况。
- 以第21天创面愈合情况作为判断创面深度的金标准。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论认为LDI预测创面愈合的准确性优于临床评估,可作为临床评估的可靠、可行且具成本效益的替代方法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE OF PRESENTATION/STUDY: To compare the accuracy of Laser Doppler Imaging (LDI) and clinical assessment in differentiating between superficial and deep partial thickness burns to decide whether early tangential excision and grafting or conservative management should be employed to optimize burn and patient management. STUDY PERIOD: March 2015 to November 2016. METHODS/PROCEDURE DETAILS: Ninety two wounds in 34 patients reporting within 5days of less than 40% burn surface area were included. Unstable patients, pregnant females and those who expired were excluded. The wounds were clinically assessed and LDI done concomitantly Plastic Surgeons blinded to each other's findings. Wound appearance, color, blanching, pain, hair follicle dislodgement were the clinical parameters that distinguished between superficial and deep partial thickness burns. On day 21, the wounds were again assessed for the presence of healing by the same plastic surgeons. The findings were correlated with the initial findings on LDI and clinical assessment and the results statistically analyzed. RESULTS/OUTCOME: The data of 92 burn wounds was analyzed using SPSS (ver. 17). Clinical assessment correctly identified the depth of 75 and LDI 83 wounds, giving diagnostic accuracies of 81.52% and 90.21% respectively. The sensitivity of clinical assessment was 81% and of LDI 92.75%, whereas the specificity was 82% for both. The positive predictive value was 93% for clinical assessment and 94% for LDI while the negative predictive value was 59% and 79% respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Predictive accuracy of LDI was found to be better than clinical assessment in the prediction of wound healing, the gold standard for wound healing being 21 days. As such it can prove to be a reliable and viable cost effective alternative per se to clinical assessment.
引用
- Jan SN, Khan FA, Bashir MM, et al. Comparison of Laser Doppler Imaging (LDI) and clinical assessment in differentiating between superficial and deep partial thickness burn wounds. Burns. 2017. PMID: 28918904. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2017.08.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。