英国烧伤住院患者两种心理筛查方法的比较
该审计比较了40例烧伤住院患者的两种心理筛查方法:一种未发表的多维度烧伤专用问卷,另一种为多学科团队会议中临床心理学家引导的心理讨论。结果显示两种方法在识别需进一步正式心理评估的患者上无差异(N=40,p=.424,双尾),但各自能发现对方遗漏的患者,提示烧伤住院心理筛查具有复杂性。
要点
- 烧伤专用问卷与MDT心理讨论在识别需正式心理评估者上无统计学差异。
- 两种方法互补,各自可发现对方未识别出的需心理干预患者。
- 烧伤住院患者心理困扰筛查需结合多种方法综合判断。
核心结论
- 烧伤专用问卷与MDT会议中心理讨论在识别需更全面心理评估的住院患者上能力相似(N=40,p=.424,双尾)。
- 两种筛查方法存在互补性,各自能识别出对方未发现的需心理支持患者。
研究设计与样本
- 一种为未发表的烧伤专用问卷,探索多个潜在困扰领域;另一种为多学科团队会议中由临床心理学家引导的心理讨论。
主要发现
- 统计分析显示两种筛查方法之间无差异(N=40,p=.424,双尾)。
- 两种方法均能识别需更正式心理评估的患者,但各自存在对方未识别的患者。
临床怎么用
- 烧伤住院患者心理筛查可考虑联合使用烧伤专用问卷与MDT心理讨论以提高识别覆盖面。
- 临床需认识到单一筛查方法可能遗漏需心理支持的患者。
局限性
- 原文未明确报告样本代表性、盲法与随访等设计细节。
- 原文未报告两种筛查方法的具体条目、评分标准及成本比较。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Various types of psychological screening are currently used in the UK to identify burn patients who are experiencing psychological distress and may need additional support and intervention during their hospital admission. This audit compared two types of psychological screening in 40 burn inpatients. One screening method was an unpublished questionnaire designed to explore multiple areas of potential distress for those who have experienced burns. The other method was an indirect psychological screen via discussions within multi-disciplinary team (MDT) meetings where a Clinical Psychologist was present to guide and prompt psychological discussions. Data was collected between November 2012 and September 2016. Results suggested that both screening methods were similar in identifying patients who benefit from more formal psychological assessment. Indeed, statistical analysis reported no difference between the two screening methods (N=40, p=.424, two-tailed). In conclusion, measuring distress in burns inpatients using a burns-specific questionnaire and psychological discussions within MDT meetings are similar in their ability to identify patients in need of more thorough psychological assessment. However, both screening methods identified patients who were in need of psychological input when the other did not. This suggests that psychological screening of burns inpatients, and the psychological difficulties that they can present with, is complex. The advantages and disadvantages of both methods of screening are discussed.
引用
- Shepherd L, Tew V, Rai L, et al. A comparison of two psychological screening methods currently used for inpatients in a UK burns service. Burns. 2017. PMID: 28778763. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2017.04.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。