严重手部烧伤酶解清创与传统手术清创的比较:选择性、疗效、愈合时间与3个月瘢痕质量
单中心对照临床试验纳入40例手部深二度烧伤患者,前20例接受传统手术清创(TSD),后20例接受菠萝蛋白酶酶解清创(EDNX)。EDNX显著缩短完全清创时间、减少清创次数、降低自体植皮需求并缩短愈合时间,3个月瘢痕质量除局部发红增加外基本相当。
要点
- EDNX较TSD显著缩短完全清创时间并减少清创次数。
- EDNX组需自体植皮比例显著低于TSD组。
- EDNX改善烧伤深度评估,3个月瘢痕质量总体相当。
核心结论
- 与TSD相比,EDNX在烧伤深度评估、组织保留、清创彻底性和创面闭合方面更优,3个月瘢痕质量无实质差异。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心对照临床试验纳入40例18至76岁手部深二度烧伤患者,前20例接受TSD,后20例接受EDNX。
主要发现
- EDNX组完全清创时间0.95天 vs TSD组7.750天,P < .001。
- EDNX组完全清创所需治疗次数1.05 vs TSD组1.45,P < .001。
- EDNX组需自体植皮比例15% vs TSD组95%,P = .034。
- EDNX组首次清创后完全愈合时间23.30天 vs TSD组32.00天,P < .001。
- 3个月早期瘢痕质量两组近乎等效,仅EDNX组局部发红加重,P < .001。
关键数值与推荐
- EDNX组初始烧伤深度高估比例为55%。
临床怎么用
- 对严重手部深二度烧伤可考虑EDNX以快速选择性清创、保留活组织并减少植皮需求。
局限性
- 单中心设计且样本量40例,既往关于EDNX在此场景的研究仅有两项已发表。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Severe burns of the hands are extremely challenging, given their anatomic complexity and vulnerability. Although excisional debridement with autografting remains the standard of care (SOC), previous studies have shown that use of enzymatic debridement with bromelain (NexoBrid, EDNX) enables rapid, selective enzymatic debridement, preserving viable tissue. To date, only two studies accruing data on EDNX in this setting have been published. The current study was conducted to compare EDNX with traditional surgical debridement (TSD) of deep dermal and full-thickness hand burns. This single-center, controlled clinical trial included 40 patients, aged 18 to 76 years, with deep dermal burns of the hand. The first 20 patients were debrided surgically, and the other 20 patients were using EDNX for debridement. Therapeutic selectivity, time to complete debridement and healing, complications, and 3-month functional/esthetic outcomes were compared by group. EDNX (vs TSD) significantly reduced time to complete debridement after admission (0.95 day vs 7.750 days; P < .001) and treatments needed for complete debridement (1.05 vs 1.45; P < .001), improving burn depth evaluation (initially overestimated in 55% of EDNX-treated patients). The number of wounds requiring autografting was certainly reduced (15% vs 95%; P = .034), as was time to complete healing after first debridement (23.30 vs 32.00 days; P < .001), and early scar quality after 3 months was nearly equivalent, with only heightened local redness in the EDNX group (P < .001). Compared with TSD, EDNX was superior in burn depth evaluation, tissue preservation, completeness of debridement, and wound closure. Scar quality after 3 months did not differ substantially.
引用
- Schulz A, Shoham Y, Rosenberg L, et al. Enzymatic Versus Traditional Surgical Debridement of Severely Burned Hands: A Comparison of Selectivity, Efficacy, Healing Time, and Three-Month Scar Quality. J Burn Care Res. 2017. PMID: 28644207. doi:10.1097/BCR.0000000000000478
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。