文献速递烧伤

烧伤阈值证据综述:时间-温度关系的批判性评价

A review of the evidence for threshold of burn injury.
PubMed 文献 · Burns · 2017-05-20

本文批判性综述了温度与时间关系决定烧伤深度及细胞死亡的证据,指出成人皮肤疼痛感知略高于43°C、表皮基底层达44°C即发生烧伤,浅表真皮烧伤损伤速率随温度线性升高呈对数增加;但全层及儿童烧伤的时间-温度关系临床验证有限,应谨慎使用。

要点

  • 成人皮肤疼痛感知略高于43°C,表皮基底层达44°C即发生烧伤。
  • 浅表真皮烧伤损伤速率随温度线性升高呈对数增加。
  • 全层烧伤及儿童烧伤的时间-温度关系临床验证有限,应慎用。

核心结论

  • 成人皮肤疼痛与浅表真皮烧伤的时间-温度关系有广泛实验建模基础和合理临床验证。
  • 全层烧伤、儿童烧伤的时间-温度关系临床验证有限,系外推数据,应谨慎使用。

研究设计与样本

  • 本文为批判性综述,总结烧伤损伤实验研究与生物传热模型,并讨论其优缺点。

主要发现

  • 体外与体内研究对浅表烧伤有广泛一致性。
  • 成人皮肤疼痛感知略高于43°C,表皮基底层达44°C时发生烧伤。
  • 浅表真皮烧伤损伤速率随温度线性升高呈对数增加。
  • 超过70°C时损伤速率过快,解读困难。
  • 烧伤深度还受皮肤厚度、血流及伤后冷却影响。

关键数值与推荐

  • 成人皮肤疼痛感知略高于43°C。
  • 表皮基底层达44°C时发生烧伤。
  • 浅表真皮烧伤损伤速率随温度线性升高呈对数增加。
  • 超过70°C时损伤速率过快,解读困难。
  • 家用热水标准建议最高温度下调3-4°C以充分保护儿童。

临床怎么用

  • 烧伤机制判断及病史一致性评估可参考成人浅表烧伤的时间-温度关系。
  • 全层烧伤及儿童烧伤的时间-温度关系临床验证有限,用于专家证据时应谨慎。

局限性

  • 深部或全层烧伤的时间-温度关系临床证据较少。
  • 儿童皮肤的时间-温度关系尚未建立。
  • 生物传热模型目前实际应用有限。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: Burn injury is common and depth is one measure of severity. Although the depth of burn injury is determined by many factors, the relationship between the temperature of the injurious agent and exposure duration, known as the time-temperature relationship, is widely accepted as one of the cornerstones of burn research. Moritz and Henriques first proposed this relationship in 1947 and their seminal work has been cited extensively. However, over the years, readers have misinterpreted their findings and incorporated misleading information about the time-temperature relationship into a wide range of industrial standards, burn prevention literature and medicolegal opinion. AIM: The purpose of this paper is to present a critical review of the evidence that relates temperature and time to cell death and the depth of burn injury. These concepts are used by researchers, burn prevention strategists, burn care teams and child protection professionals involved in ascertaining how the mechanism of burning relates to the injury pattern and whether the injury is consistent with the history. REVIEW METHODS: This review explores the robustness of the currently available evidence. The paper summarises the research from burn damage experimental work as well as bioheat transfer models and discusses the merits and limitations of these approaches. REVIEW FINDINGS: There is broad agreement between in vitro and in vivo studies for superficial burns. There is clear evidence that the perception of pain in adult human skin occurs just above 43°C. When the basal layer of the epidermis reaches 44°C, burn injury occurs. For superficial dermal burns, the rate of tissue damage increases logarithmically with a linear increase in temperature. Beyond 70°C, rate of damage is so rapid that interpretation can be difficult. Depth of injury is also influenced by skin thickness, blood flow and cooling after injury. There is less clinical evidence for a time-temperature relationship for deep or subdermal burns. Bioheat transfer models are useful in research and becoming increasingly sophisticated but currently have limited practical use. Time-temperature relationships have not been established for burns in children's skin, although standards for domestic hot water suggest that the maximum temperature should be revised downward by 3-4°C to provide adequate burn protection for children. CONCLUSION: Time-temperature relationships established for pain and superficial dermal burns in adult human skin have an extensive experimental modeling basis and reasonable clinical validation. However, time-temperature relationships for subdermal burns, full thickness burns and burn injury in children have limited clinical validation, being extrapolated from other data, and should be used with caution, particularly if presented during expert evidence.

来源:Burns,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Martin NA, Falder S. A review of the evidence for threshold of burn injury. Burns. 2017. PMID: 28536038. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2017.04.003

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。