面部深度烧伤酶性清创与传统手术清创的愈合与早期瘢痕比较
单中心临床试验纳入26例临床评估为深二度及更深的面部烧伤患者,比较酶性清创与手术清创。酶性清创显著缩短创面完全闭合时间(19.85天 vs 42.23天,p=0.002),减少清创操作次数(1.00 vs 1.77,p=0.003),降低自体植皮比例(15% vs 77%,p=0.002),且12个月后多项瘢痕质量指标更优。
要点
- 酶性清创缩短面部深度烧伤创面闭合时间并减少手术次数。
- 酶性清创组自体植皮比例显著低于手术清创组。
- 酶性清创后12个月瘢痕色素、厚度、柔软度等多项指标更优。
核心结论
- 基于菠萝蛋白酶的酶性清创在面部深二度烧伤的组织保留某些方面优于传统手术清创。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心临床试验纳入26例年龄18-78岁、临床评估为深二度或更深的面部烧伤患者,比较酶性清创与切除性手术清创。
主要发现
- 酶性清创组创面完全闭合时间显著短于手术清创组(19.85天 vs 42.23天,p=0.002)。
- 酶性清创组完成清创的操作次数显著少于手术清创组(1.00 vs 1.77,p=0.003)。
- 77%经酶性清创的面部烧伤实际烧伤深度比初始评估更浅。
- 酶性清创组任何面积的自体植皮比例显著降低(15% vs 77%,p=0.002)。
- 12个月后酶性清创组瘢痕质量在色素沉着(p=0.016)、柔软度(p=0.01)、表面积(p=0.004)、僵硬(p=0.023)、厚度(0.011)和不规则(p=0.011)等方面优于手术清创组。
临床怎么用
- 对于临床评估为深二度或更深的面部烧伤,可考虑采用基于菠萝蛋白酶的酶性清创以保留更多组织。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Facial burns occur frequently and depending on the injured skin layers often heal with scars which may cause permanent functional and cosmetic sequelae. Preservation of the sensitive facial skin layers, especially of the dermis is essential for scarless epithelialisation. Enzymatic debridement of deep thermal burns has already been shown to assist with preserving viable dermis. However, up to date, there are no published reports on wound healing and in the long term aesthetic outcome after enzymatic debridement of facial burns. METHODS: Therefore we performed a-single centre clinical trial that included 26 subjects aged 18-78 years with facial burns clinically evaluated as deep dermal or deeper. Burns were treated either with enzymatic debridement or excisional surgical debridement. Then we compared both groups regarding debridement selectivity, wound closure and scar quality after more than 12 months. RESULTS: Enzymatic debridement significantly reduced time to complete wound closure after admission (19.85 days versus 42.23 days, p=0.002), and after enzymatic eschar removal (18.92 days versus 35.62 days, p=0.042). The number of procedures to complete debridement were significantly lower in the enzymatic debridement group (1.00 versus 1.77, p=0.003). 77% of facial burns that had been debrided enzymatically were found to be more superficially burned than initially estimated. Wounds undergoing autografting of any size were significantly reduced by enzymatic debridement (15% versus 77%, p=0.002). Scar quality after enzymatic debridement was superior compared to surgical debridement after 12 months regarding pigmentation (p=0.016), thickness (p=0.16), relief (p=0.10), pliability (p=0.01), surface area (p=0.004), stiffness (p=0.023), thickness (0.011) and scar irregularity (p=0.011). Regarding erythema and melanin, viscoelasticity and pliability, trans-epidermal water loss or laser tissue oxygen saturation, haemoglobin level and microcirculation we found no significant differences for treated and untreated skin in the EDNX group. CONCLUSION: In our current study we found Bromelain based enzymatic debridement better in some aspects of tissue preservation in deep dermal facial burn.
引用
- Schulz A, Fuchs PC, Rothermundt I, et al. Enzymatic debridement of deeply burned faces: Healing and early scarring based on tissue preservation compared to traditional surgical debridement. Burns. 2017. PMID: 28363663. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2017.02.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。