解剖型与圆形假体隆乳术中的美学比较:一项随机对照试验
该随机对照试验纳入75例初次隆乳患者,同一患者一侧置入圆形硅胶假体、另一侧置入解剖型假体,术中拍照后由10名整形外科医生和10名普通评审者进行盲法美学评估。结果显示两组假体在乳房美学上无显著差异,整形医生仅在26.5%的病例中正确识别假体形状,不支持解剖型假体在隆乳中具有美学优势。
要点
- 解剖型与圆形假体在隆乳美学评估中无显著差异。
- 整形医生仅26.5%的病例能正确识别假体形状。
- 解剖型假体缺乏美学优势,不支持继续常规使用。
核心结论
- 本研究提供高级别证据支持解剖型假体在隆乳中并不优于圆形假体。
- 鉴于解剖型假体具有重要且独特的缺点,缺乏美学优势不支持其继续在隆乳中使用。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,75例初次隆乳患者,同一患者一侧置入圆形硅胶假体、另一侧置入解剖型硅胶假体。
- 术中拍照后由10名整形外科医生和10名普通评审者进行盲法美学评估。
主要发现
- 整形医生报告43.6%的病例中两种假体无美学差异,普通评审者报告29.2%的病例无差异。
- 整形医生判断解剖型侧更优的病例占51.1%,圆形侧更优占48.9%(p=0.496)。
- 普通评审者判断解剖型侧更优的病例占46.7%,圆形侧更优占53.3%(p=0.140)。
- 整形医生仅26.5%的病例正确识别假体形状。
临床怎么用
- 在隆乳假体选择时,不应仅基于美学优势的假设优先选择解剖型假体。
- 需综合考虑解剖型假体的独特缺点与缺乏美学优势的证据进行临床决策。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The purpose of this randomized controlled trial was to determine whether anatomical implants are aesthetically superior to round implants in breast augmentation. METHODS: Seventy-five patients undergoing primary breast augmentation had a round silicone implant of optimal volume, projection, and diameter placed in one breast and an anatomical silicone device of similar volume and optimal shape placed in the other. After intraoperative photographs were taken, the anatomical device was replaced by a round implant to complete the procedure. A survey designed to measure breast aesthetics was administered to 10 plastic surgeon and 10 lay reviewers for blind evaluation of the 75 cases. RESULTS: No observable difference in breast aesthetics between anatomical and round implants was reported by plastic surgeons in 43.6 percent or by lay individuals in 29.2 percent of cases. When a difference was perceived, neither plastic surgeons nor lay individuals preferred the anatomical side more often than the round side. Plastic surgeons judged the anatomical side superior in 51.1 percent of cases and the round side superior in 48.9 percent of cases (p = 0.496). Lay individuals judged the anatomical side superior in 46.7 percent of cases and the round side superior in 53.3 percent (p = 0.140). Plastic surgeons identified implant shape correctly in only 26.5 percent of cases. CONCLUSIONS: This study provides high-level evidence supporting no aesthetic superiority of anatomical over round implants. Given that anatomical implants have important and unique disadvantages, a lack of proven aesthetic superiority argues against their continued use in breast augmentation. CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic, I.
引用
- Hidalgo DA, Weinstein AL. Intraoperative Comparison of Anatomical versus Round Implants in Breast Augmentation: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2017. PMID: 28234826. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000003114
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。