双反向Z成形术联合或不联合颊瓣修复腭裂:505例连续病例回顾
回顾性分析505例采用双反向Z成形术(Furlow法)联合或不联合颊瓣修复腭裂的患者,评估鼻音共鸣、二期言语手术及术后并发症。结果显示平均鼻音共鸣评分1.38,两组相当,尽管颊瓣组宽腭裂比例显著更高(56% vs 8%);腭咽闭合不全二期手术率6.6%,瘘管率6.1%,大瘘管(>2 mm)率2.7%。结论认为该术式是标准腭裂修复的有效替代,言语结果优良且并发症少,颊瓣使Furlow修复适用于任何大小的腭裂而无需松弛切口。
要点
- 双反向Z成形术联合或不联合颊瓣修复腭裂,言语结果优良且并发症少。
- 颊瓣组宽腭裂比例更高(56% vs 8%),但鼻音共鸣评分与不联合颊瓣组相当。
- 二期腭咽闭合不全手术率6.6%,瘘管率6.1%,大瘘管(>2 mm)率2.7%。
核心结论
- 双反向Z成形术联合或不联合颊瓣是标准腭裂修复的有效替代方案。
- 颊瓣使Furlow修复可应用于任何大小的腭裂,无需松弛切口。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入505例连续接受双反向Z成形术联合或不联合颊瓣修复的腭裂患者。
- 比较单纯双反向Z成形术组与联合颊瓣组,结局包括鼻音共鸣、二期言语手术及术后并发症。
- 证据等级:治疗性,III级。
主要发现
- 平均鼻音共鸣评分为1.38,单纯双反向Z成形术组与联合颊瓣组相当。
- 颊瓣组宽腭裂比例显著更高(56% vs 8%)。
- 腭咽闭合不全二期手术率为6.6%,瘘管率为6.1%,大瘘管(>2 mm)率为2.7%。
关键数值与推荐
- 宽腭裂比例:颊瓣组56%,单纯双反向Z成形术组8%。
- 平均鼻音共鸣评分:1.38。
- 腭咽闭合不全二期手术率:6.6%;瘘管率:6.1%;大瘘管(>2 mm)率:2.7%。
临床怎么用
- 对于宽腭裂,可考虑在双反向Z成形术基础上联合颊瓣,以避免松弛切口并应用Furlow修复。
- 该术式言语结果优良且并发症少,可作为标准腭裂修复的替代选择。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计,证据等级为III级。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Standard methods of cleft palate repair rely on existing palatal tissue to achieve closure. These procedures often require relaxing incisions, causing scars and growth restriction, and may result in insufficient palatal length and suboptimal positioning of the velar musculature. The Furlow double opposing Z-plasty improves palatal length and repositions the velar musculature; however, relaxing incisions may still be needed. The addition of buccal flaps to the Furlow repair obviates the need for relaxing incisions and allows the Furlow repair to be used in wide clefts. METHODS: A retrospective review was performed on 505 patients; all patients were treated with the double opposing Z-plasty plus or minus buccal flap approach. Outcomes included nasal resonance, secondary speech surgery, and postoperative complications. A comparison was made between patients treated with double opposing Z-plasty alone and those treated with double opposing Z-plasty plus buccal flaps. RESULTS: The average nasal resonance score was 1.38 and was equivalent in both the double opposing Z-plasty alone and with buccal flap groups, despite significantly more wide clefts in the buccal flap group (56 percent versus 8 percent). The secondary surgery rate for velopharyngeal insufficiency was 6.6 percent and the fistula rate was 6.1 percent. The large fistula rate (>2 mm) was 2.7 percent. CONCLUSIONS: The double opposing Z-plasty plus or minus buccal flap approach is a useful alternative to standard palate repairs. Speech outcomes were excellent, even in wider clefts, and postoperative complications were minimal. Buccal flaps allow the benefits of the Furlow repair to be applied to any size cleft, without the need for relaxing incisions. CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic, III.
引用
- Mann RJ, Martin MD, Eichhorn MG, et al. The Double Opposing Z-Plasty Plus or Minus Buccal Flap Approach for Repair of Cleft Palate: A Review of 505 Consecutive Cases. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2017. PMID: 28234851. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000003127
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。