文献速递烧伤创面修复

监狱烧伤诊疗中的伦理困境:双重忠诚与健康公平

Burn Care in Prisons: Ethical Dilemmas in Correctional Health Care.
PubMed 文献 · J Burn Care Res · 2026-08-18

该叙述性综述检索PubMed、Embase和Scopus(2000-2025年英文文献),探讨被监禁烧伤患者面临的伦理与临床障碍。核心发现是双重忠诚——对患者的义务与对监所或国家的义务之间的冲突——是伦理冲突的主要驱动因素,表现为专科烧伤中心可及性受限、知情同意受损、康复服务不足及制度性忽视导致的痛苦。作者呼吁提升监狱烧伤诊疗在学术与倡导中的关注度。

要点

  • 双重忠诚是被监禁烧伤患者伦理冲突的核心驱动因素
  • 专科烧伤中心可及性受限、知情同意在监管下受损、康复服务不足
  • 需在烧伤学术与倡导中提升监狱烧伤诊疗的能见度

核心结论

  • 被监禁烧伤患者的诊疗在文献与专业讨论中存在重大空白,双重忠诚是伦理冲突的核心驱动因素。
  • 提升监狱烧伤诊疗在烧伤学术与倡导中的地位,是维护诊疗标准的必要举措。
  • 明确关注双重忠诚可支持在维护机构安全的同时保护患者尊严的改革。

研究设计与样本

  • 叙述性综述,检索PubMed、Embase和Scopus(英文文献,2000-2025年),纳入同行评议文章、立场声明和伦理分析。
  • 采用主题综合方法识别反复出现的伦理张力、临床障碍和潜在解决框架。

主要发现

  • 反复出现的主题包括专科烧伤中心可及性受限、监管下知情同意受损、康复服务不足及与制度性忽视相关的不成比例痛苦。
  • 双重忠诚常使患者尊严与惩教权威对立,是伦理冲突的中心驱动因素。
  • 被监禁烧伤患者在文献与专业讨论中 largely 缺席。

临床怎么用

  • 临床医生应明确识别并管理双重忠诚冲突,在维护机构安全的同时保护患者尊严。
  • 应关注被监禁烧伤患者获得专科烧伤中心、知情同意和康复服务的障碍。
  • 烧伤学术与倡导应将监狱烧伤诊疗纳入议程,以推动改革和改善结局。

局限性

  • 叙述性综述,检索限于英文文献(2000-2025年),可能存在语言和发表偏倚。
  • 被监禁烧伤患者相关文献本身存在重大空白,限制了证据的深度和广度。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Burn injuries among incarcerated individuals represent an underexplored intersection of medical ethics, correctional policy, and health equity. Although scholarship increasingly examines vulnerable groups such as refugees and undocumented patients, incarcerated burn patients remain largely absent. Dual loyalty-balancing duty to the patient with obligations to the institution or state-creates distinctive challenges that are intensified in burn care, where timely intervention, pain control, rehabilitation, and psychosocial support are critical but often constrained by security protocols and systemic neglect. We conducted a narrative review of PubMed, Embase, and Scopus to identify peer-reviewed articles, position statements, and ethical analyses addressing incarcerated healthcare, dual loyalty, and burn treatment (English-language, 2000-2025). A thematic synthesis identified recurring ethical tensions, clinical barriers, and potential frameworks for resolution. Findings highlight a major gap in both literature and professional discourse. Recurrent themes included restricted access to specialized burn centers, compromised informed consent under custodial oversight, inadequate rehabilitative services, and disproportionate suffering linked to institutional neglect. Dual loyalty emerged as a central driver of ethical conflict, often pitting patient dignity against correctional authority. Elevating incarcerated burn care within burn scholarship and advocacy is necessary to uphold standards of care. Explicit attention to dual loyalty can support reforms that preserve patient dignity while maintaining institutional safety, improve outcomes, and reaffirm professional ethical commitments.

来源:J Burn Care Res,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Khorsandi J, Mirharooni J, Kahen M, et al. Burn Care in Prisons: Ethical Dilemmas in Correctional Health Care. J Burn Care Res. 2026. PMID: 42610983. doi:10.1093/jbcr/irag139

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。