谁被视为「顶尖」整形外科医生?国家排名中的性别差异与医生集中度
该研究回顾《新闻周刊》「美国最佳整形外科医生」五年排名共720条记录,识别出149名唯一医生,其中男性134名(89.9%)、女性15名(10.1%)。女性整形外科医生在国家排名中的比例显著低于其约20%的劳动力占比(10.1% vs 20%;p=0.002)。排名还存在重复上榜与地域集中现象,提示需重新评估调查方法与排名流程。
要点
- 女性在排名中占10.1%,显著低于约20%的劳动力占比(p=0.002)。
- 35.6%的医生出现在多个类别,平均额外列出2.3个类别。
- 2025年同类别既往上榜者平均已上榜2.8次,提示集中效应。
核心结论
- 「美国最佳整形外科医生」榜单存在显著性别差异,且重复上榜模式可能提示医生集中于有限子集。
- 重新评估调查方法与排名流程可能改善代表性和患者获得更多元医生选择的机会。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析《新闻周刊》发布的年度「美国最佳整形外科医生」排名,共回顾720条排名记录。
- 排名基于同行提名调查,涵盖六个美容手术类别,每类识别前30名医生。
- 记录医生性别与地点,去除重复条目识别唯一医生,并评估跨类别重复上榜情况。
主要发现
- 720条排名记录中识别出149名唯一医生,其中男性134名(89.9%)、女性15名(10.1%)。
- 女性整形外科医生在排名中的比例显著低于其约20%的全国劳动力占比(10.1% vs 20%;p=0.002)。
- 每年女性代表比例均显著低于预期(2021年 p=0.004;2022-2025年所有 p<0.001)。
- 与各自首年相比,女性医生比例在四个类别中下降。
- 35.6%的医生(n=53)出现在一个以上类别,平均额外列出2.3个类别;2025年同类别既往上榜者平均已上榜2.8次。
临床怎么用
- 解读「最佳医生」榜单时应意识到性别代表不足与重复上榜可能带来的集中偏倚。
- 患者咨询时可参考更广泛的多元医生来源,而非仅依赖单一商业排名。
- 学科与机构可关注排名方法学对代表性和患者选择的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Newsweek has published annual "America's Best Plastic Surgeons" rankings based on a peer-nomination survey for five years, now encompassing six aesthetic surgery categories that each identify the top 30 surgeons. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate gender representation, geographic distribution, and recurrence patterns among surgeons included in these national rankings. METHODS: All available ranked surgeons were reviewed (n=720). Surgeon gender and location were recorded. Duplicate entries were removed to identify unique surgeons. Recurrence across categories was evaluated. RESULTS: Of the 720 rankings published, 149 unique surgeons were identified. 134 (89.9%) were male and 15 (10.1%) were female. Compared with their estimated 20% representation in the national workforce, female plastic surgeons were significantly underrepresented in the rankings (10.1% vs 20%; p=0.002). Each year, female representation was significantly lower than expected (2021, p=0.004; 2022-2025, all p<0.001). Compared with their respective inaugural years, the proportion of female surgeons decreased in four categories. 35.6% of surgeons (n=53) appeared in more than one category, averaging 2.3 additional category listings. In 2025, surgeons previously ranked within the same category had appeared on average 2.8 times before. Geographically, surgeons were located in the South (n=54), Northeast (n=52), West (n=29), and Midwest (n=14). CONCLUSIONS: Significant gender disparities characterize the "America's Best Plastic Surgeons" lists, and redundancy patterns may indicate concentration among a limited subset of surgeons. Reevaluating survey methodology and the ranking process may improve representation and patient access to a more diverse selection of surgeons.
引用
- Knauer G, Kalra A, Gupta A, et al. Who Is Recognized as a "Top" Plastic Surgeon? Gender Disparities and Surgeon Concentration in National Rankings. Aesthet Surg J. 2026. PMID: 42530434. doi:10.1093/asj/sjag158
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。