2026年整形外科的多样性、公平与包容:更新综述与新建议
文章普遍支持DEI倡议,但作者认为黑人及西班牙裔申请者少是入行人数少而非「泄漏管道」,种族匹配不可取,相关建议的合宪性需重新审视。
要点
- 常见关键词包括diversity、inclusion、mentorship、equity、underrepresented、disparity、barriers和leaky pipeline。
- 作者结论:黑人及西班牙裔并非因障碍而代表不足,而是进入管道申请者本身较少;种族匹配不可取。
核心结论
- 未证实黑人及西班牙裔因障碍而代表不足,证据显示进入管道的申请者本身较少,而非「泄漏管道」。
- 种族匹配(按种族匹配医生与患者)不可取。
- 持续发表忽视建议合宪性与合法性的亲DEI文章需要重新考虑。
主要发现
- 常见关键词为diversity、inclusion、mentorship、equity、underrepresented、disparity、barriers和leaky pipeline。
- 文章一致提出支持DEI倡议的建议,招募与赞助代表不足申请者是常见主题。
临床怎么用
- 整形外科DEI相关建议需同时考虑美国最高法院裁定与现行法律框架。
- 关注代表不足申请者的招募与赞助,而非仅归因于管道泄漏。
- 对按种族匹配医生与患者的做法持审慎态度。
局限性
- 为叙述性综述,未报告系统检索策略、筛选流程或偏倚评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The June 2023 Supreme Court decision against affirmative action and the November 2024 US election impacted American universities and companies nationwide, many of which have ended their diversity, equity, inclusion (DEI) programs. This review was undertaken to assess the impact of these events, if any, on DEI publications in plastic surgery. It also examines the core issues-barriers to minorities, equity, a leaky pipeline, and racial concordance. METHOD: Six plastic surgery journals were queried from January 2024 to December 2025 using the search term "diversity." The recommendations and keywords were evaluated. RESULTS: Sixty articles were identified. Publications commonly evaluated racial and gender compositions of plastic surgery trainees, academic surgeons, websites, presentations, and publications. Frequent keywords included: diversity, inclusion, mentorship, equity, underrepresented, disparity, barriers, and a leaky pipeline. The publications uniformly made recommendations in favor of DEI initiatives. The recruitment and sponsorship of underrepresented applicants was a common theme. DISCUSSION: The plastic surgery literature almost exclusively supports DEI initiatives. However, recent federal lawsuits underscore the risk of continuing racial preferences, which have been ruled unconstitutional by the US Supreme Court. Many keywords and recommendations contrast sharply with the US Supreme Court decision. Moreover, an unrecognized shift in demographics has taken place over the last 4 decades. Whites are now underrepresented in medical schools compared with the US population. CONCLUSIONS: It has not been demonstrated that Blacks or Hispanics are underrepresented because of barriers. The evidence shows that there are simply fewer Black and Hispanic applicants entering the pipeline, as opposed to a "leaky pipeline." Racial concordance - aligning providers and patients by race - cannot be condoned. The need for continued pro-DEI publications that overlook the constitutionality and legality of their recommendations warrants reconsideration.
引用
- Swanson E. Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in Plastic Surgery in 2026: An Updated Review and New Recommendations. Ann Plast Surg. 2026. PMID: 42485158. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000004828
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。