文献速递美容整形颅颌面外科

自体与同种异体肋软骨移植在鼻中隔鼻成形术中的不良结局与并发症:系统综述与Meta分析

Adverse Outcomes and Complications of Autologous Versus Homologous Costal Cartilage Grafts in Septorhinoplasty: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis.
PubMed 文献 · Aesthet Surg J · 2026-06-30

该系统综述与Meta分析遵循PRISMA指南,纳入50项研究共4,482例患者,评估自体肋软骨、辐照同种异体肋软骨、Tutoplast处理软骨及新鲜冷冻肋软骨移植的并发症率。随机效应Meta分析显示总体并发症率低:翘曲2.9%、吸收1.6%、感染1.9%、挤出0.0%、翻修手术5.0%、患者不满意4.0%。各移植物类型间所有结局均无显著差异(均P > .05),提示安全性相当;但研究偏倚风险高且异质性大,结论需谨慎解读。

要点

  • 各类型肋软骨移植总体并发症率低,且相互间无显著差异。
  • 自体肋软骨背侧覆盖移植中,叠层构造翘曲率显著低于整块移植(0.0% vs 5.42%;P = .004)。
  • 整块背侧移植中,新鲜冷冻软骨翘曲率最低(0.60%),显著低于自体肋软骨(P = .030)。

核心结论

  • 自体与同种异体肋软骨移植在鼻中隔鼻成形术中的并发症率总体较低且类型间无显著差异,移植物选择可基于可得性、成本和术者经验而非单纯并发症率差异。

研究设计与样本

  • 遵循PRISMA指南的系统综述与Meta分析,纳入50项研究共4,482例患者(自体肋软骨n = 1,951;Tutoplast n = 1,200;辐照同种异体肋软骨n = 676;新鲜冷冻n = 629)。

主要发现

  • 随机效应Meta分析显示合并并发症率:翘曲2.9%、吸收1.6%、感染1.9%、挤出0.0%、翻修手术5.0%、患者不满意4.0%。
  • 各移植物类型间所有结局均无显著差异(均P > .05)。
  • 自体肋软骨背侧覆盖移植中,叠层构造翘曲率显著低于整块移植(0.0% vs 5.42%;P = .004)。
  • 整块背侧移植中,新鲜冷冻软骨翘曲率最低(0.60%),显著低于自体肋软骨(P = .030)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 自体肋软骨背侧覆盖移植:叠层构造翘曲率0.0% vs 整块5.42%(P = .004)。
  • 整块背侧移植:新鲜冷冻软骨翘曲率0.60%,显著低于自体肋软骨(P = .030)。
  • 各类型间所有结局比较均P > .05。

临床怎么用

  • 肋软骨移植物选择可综合考虑可得性、成本和术者经验,而非仅依据并发症率差异。
  • 自体肋软骨背侧覆盖移植时,叠层构造可能降低翘曲风险。
  • 整块背侧移植时,新鲜冷冻软骨翘曲率较低可供参考。

局限性

  • ROBINS-I评估偏倚风险为严重至临界,存在小样本效应证据。
  • 研究以回顾性设计为主,异质性大,结论需谨慎解读。
  • 需要前瞻性、标准化及长期随访研究。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Costal cartilage is frequently used in rhinoplasty when septal cartilage is insufficient; however, comparative data across different processing methods remain limited. This systematic review and meta-analysis evaluated complication rates associated with autologous costal cartilage (ACC), irradiated homologous costal cartilage (IHCC), Tutoplast-processed cartilage, and fresh-frozen costal cartilage grafts. Following the PRISMA guidelines, 50 studies comprising 4,482 patients were included (ACC, n = 1,951; Tutoplast, n = 1,200; IHCC, n = 676; fresh frozen, n = 629). Random-effects meta-analysis demonstrated low pooled complication rates: warping (2.9%), resorption (1.6%), infection (1.9%), extrusion (0.0%), revision surgery (5.0%), and patient dissatisfaction (4.0%). No significant differences were observed among graft types for any outcome (all P > .05), suggesting comparable safety profiles. Configuration and processing influenced specific outcomes. For ACC dorsal onlay grafts, laminated constructs showed significantly lower warping rates than en bloc grafts (0.0% vs 5.42%; P = .004). Among en bloc dorsal grafts across all types, fresh-frozen cartilage demonstrated the lowest warping rate (0.60%), significantly lower than ACC (P = .030). Risk of bias, assessed using the ROBINS-I tool, was serious to critical across studies, with evidence of small-study effects. Given the predominance of retrospective designs and substantial heterogeneity, findings should be interpreted cautiously. Graft selection may therefore be guided by availability, cost, and surgeon experience rather than differences in complication rates alone. Prospective, standardized studies with long-term follow-up are warranted.

来源:Aesthet Surg J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jullamusi W, Kowitwibool K, Mungmee A, et al. Adverse Outcomes and Complications of Autologous Versus Homologous Costal Cartilage Grafts in Septorhinoplasty: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Aesthet Surg J. 2026. PMID: 42374829. doi:10.1093/asj/sjag131

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。